review-eaaed7e52a7a55b113d0 review report

{"review_lineage_id":"eaaed7e52a7a55b113d003244bb5dac6b45a47a12b5c41c0643611af34a560a0","review_run_id":"464d30539e626afc2bac8998fa4400f3133a086613187f09d70a89b28df0d29d","accepted_bounds_identity":"issue-205-spec@530705a276f47a3f4391466b4c629f2d003728a8","accepted_bounds_hash":"370b4fb2a099927df2d2293e29808144bb9df5ca067b38963d9bcf566718962b","reviewed_at":"20260915T093941Z","mode":"delivery","normalized_target":{"kind":"delivery-git-diff","locator":"repo:wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence","actual_base_ref":"0ea9acee128fd4a9c632d9647c12a2a88d980e3d","fixed_point_sha":"0ea9acee128fd4a9c632d9647c12a2a88d980e3d","head_identity":"09569c66ca6fa744f315360ddac7ec838d1e663e","inclusive_scope":["BASELINE_CHANGELOG.md","apps/cli/scripts/sync-skills-repo.mjs","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/cli/hi-cli/references/commands.md","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/cli/hi-cli/references/post-command-flow.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-backend-structure/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-backend-structure/references/layout.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-service-design/SKILL.md","apps/cli/src/scripts/sync-skills-repo.test.ts","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/meta.json","docs/README.md","docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md"],"canonical_patch_hash":"10633f3bb42a0c23d71c62a2a3ba12751a263f30d839f9875a5ec83719e0ea58"},"snapshot_hash":"3857ebf5c8ac40a24d45fce51b225b5c2767e46a9d35e505ff891589f56e2aae","excluded_envelope":["apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-eaaed7e52a7a55b113d0-20260915T093941Z-3857ebf5c8ac-review-report.md"],"source_paths_and_hashes":[{"path":"AGENTS.md","hash":"9e44b149270d3405ea72734691b84dc999db0a12e8838acb26845ec1ce950a07"},{"path":"apps/cli/AGENTS.md","hash":"8ddeed635076e050608ee20d71f1c6dc1b8c4b2aa3faea33a05e3ebf99b2c9a1"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/agnostic/docs/writing-for-agents/SKILL.md","hash":"a842323e664e5af104eac5c97ad22fda929ebeb62d81c501161ac1f6f482db58"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/agnostic/quality/codebase-design/SKILL.md","hash":"a4b22a33f658d4cff395aed88eb6752dca8f929b57a2f129aba366236866a145"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/agnostic/quality/simplify/SKILL.md","hash":"fd32fd22d1f6faea21c106a5f2524fa625e9a5eb3e4b9a5b7900693aefb8e2d5"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/agnostic/quality/tdd/SKILL.md","hash":"1e72cad2cc455bd77e3da51d9448f45b40a9f0f3b74f00424b209233c5744b1c"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-backend-structure/SKILL.md","hash":"2146682f04af5ed5a8e3d2925096cfab955114c48d9a7af8a912bf349a01101a"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-backend-structure/references/layout.md","hash":"41d8004c80d8ead3f60ae8cf1ab50f7d3c36cfecc3317602aac40f6cf02fd9f8"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-service-design/SKILL.md","hash":"d4f538d182ee929f2645e5e6172da0119c856dad387f5240ea4ad5bf58720aa1"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/languages/typescript/quality-types/SKILL.md","hash":"109aebda778b096b325c92da4afd3dc4ba712ff44a2bd70b1962faea88be88a3"},{"path":"apps/cli/skills/phases/review-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"60cc11940f099840c84107338da4f462f952503cffb4dfe3a52392b57f11a803"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/AGENTS.md","hash":"9a5033a9c2e4d77a84402117635c589c9ac56e14a00d9a6dede5f788df5bda53"},{"path":"apps/wiki/AGENTS.md","hash":"998467e95c421760bafe60ba51ff07fbb2f75961b7fac4c4ed3106ea7f3ee14d"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"30cfc824b838345de466596b3a189d7f5b02c30b5a52ba2d28cd7096a2de5d84"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/PLAN.md","hash":"1bd1b79a6ac0a768a5f3704c1a7f239c02782b69284984c4fdd52b38fa20be1d"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/SPEC.md","hash":"6f0b795ef3a5970b3f8074779f0a628d340675c46e7a4092bcb8a51830155137"},{"path":"docs/AGENTS.md","hash":"599c64fde205da1e408469956bbf0da58994aec533bbb8291b206b65c64121e1"}],"source_set_hash":"0b4c86b64c1f62d936de3048c22906fcf9aeca9782664ef6a1806c5b76160eb2","lens_outcomes":{"standards":"findings","skill_adherence":"clean","architecture":"clean","simplify":"clean","spec":"clean"},"findings":[{"id":"f001-default-sync-ref-does-not-resolve-pin","lens":"standards","severity":"high","location":"apps/cli/scripts/sync-skills-repo.mjs:20","impact":"A normal `bun run sync:skills` fetches moving `main` but requires it to equal the older #205 commit, so default synchronization fails as soon as main advances.","evidence":"The frozen script sets defaultRepositoryRef to main and defaultRepositoryCommit to 4e2496c5982caf6e53c526d5ecc0acf031e4853a; source origin/main resolves to e780042a0a0e420dde1c5611ec62dac7b0517543, while the immutable issue-205 tag peels to 4e2496c5982caf6e53c526d5ecc0acf031e4853a.","action":"Make the default ref resolve the pinned immutable tag, or otherwise make the default ref and expected commit one stable pair; retain an override only for explicit alternate sources.","return_route":"implementation"}],"routing":{"primary":"implementation","secondary_architecture_follow_up":false},"validation":[{"command":"node --test /home/stefan/repos/skills/tests/backend-structure-composition.contract.test.mjs && git -C /home/stefan/repos/skills diff --check","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"3857ebf5c8ac40a24d45fce51b225b5c2767e46a9d35e505ff891589f56e2aae","after_hash":"3857ebf5c8ac40a24d45fce51b225b5c2767e46a9d35e505ff891589f56e2aae","outcome":"passed","evidence":"Canonical contract passed 3/3; source diff check passed."},{"command":"bun run --cwd /tmp/issue205-validation/apps/cli test src/scripts/sync-skills-repo.test.ts","isolation":"disposable-checkout","before_hash":"3857ebf5c8ac40a24d45fce51b225b5c2767e46a9d35e505ff891589f56e2aae","after_hash":"3857ebf5c8ac40a24d45fce51b225b5c2767e46a9d35e505ff891589f56e2aae","outcome":"skipped","evidence":"Disposable checkout lacks installed vitest (exit 127); no frozen target mutation."}],"delivery_goal_identity":"github:wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence#205","review_ordinal":1,"preceding_repair_ordinal":null,"review_epoch":{"protocol":"primary-challenger-v1","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","results":[{"reviewer_identity":"issue205-parent-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"standards","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","outcome":"findings","candidates":[{"location":"apps/cli/scripts/sync-skills-repo.mjs:20","evidence_pointer":"frozen script default selection and source remote readback","impact":"default sync cannot fetch its expected immutable commit after main advances","proposed_severity":"high","proposed_return_route":"implementation","uncertainty":"none"}],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue205-parent-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"skill_adherence","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue205-parent-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"architecture","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue205-parent-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"simplify","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue205-parent-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"spec","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue205-parent-challenger","role":"challenger","coverage":"immutable-sync-selection","packet_identity":"8d4fe94461b9412fe3feb61e195995b091fddcaeb2c3f3a5ee7e42c2c8d21958","outcome":"findings","candidates":[{"location":"apps/cli/scripts/sync-skills-repo.mjs:20","evidence_pointer":"independent default-ref and immutable-tag readback","impact":"default path selects an advancing branch while asserting a fixed commit","proposed_severity":"high","proposed_return_route":"implementation","uncertainty":"none"}],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null}],"adjudications":[{"candidate_refs":["[\"issue205-parent-primary\",\"standards\",0]","[\"issue205-parent-challenger\",\"immutable-sync-selection\",0]"],"finding_id":"f001-default-sync-ref-does-not-resolve-pin","evidence":"Both independently verified candidates describe the same frozen default-selection defect; the canonical source and generated Effect bytes otherwise satisfy the scoped guidance and ownership requirements."}]}}