{"review_lineage_id":"af60c94612b40a4186231134c9617ae2ed14ac9ea487bc530c4163062f4a0318","review_run_id":"e2603cb2f9992e9153795ba31930ff9f79838886d99b350bab7e75fe6a245e24","accepted_bounds_identity":"issue-217:SPEC:2026-09-22:bun-1.4","accepted_bounds_hash":"8da3ea761d16ff7014ad5d30ec100cfda88965162aaf5d65e615a96bc8bdc1bd","reviewed_at":"20260922T110444Z","mode":"delivery","normalized_target":{"kind":"delivery-git-diff","locator":"https://github.com/wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence/pull/223","actual_base_ref":"origin/team/stefan/cli-update-quick-fixes","fixed_point_sha":"4d4b7b71622ee90228143af57f995f0f6de4bff8","head_identity":"worktree:eae8755700d09d09678df58a81b1ce492258b1a2b538e7d04860b0f651920f8b","inclusive_scope":[".agents/rules/apps/web-thin-surface.md",".github/workflows/behavior-contract.yml",".github/workflows/cache-reuse-witness.yml",".github/workflows/external-drift.yml",".github/workflows/release.yml","apps/api/package.json","apps/api/src/features/public-domain-root-contract.test.ts","apps/api/src/integrations/persistence/report-repository.test.ts","apps/backoffice/package.json","apps/backoffice/src/modules/control-plane/cache-tags.test.ts","apps/backoffice/src/public-routes.test.tsx","apps/cli/package.json","apps/cli/scripts/package-bundled-gitignore.mjs","apps/cli/src/cli/behavioral-portfolio.test.ts","apps/cli/src/cli/portfolio-catalog.test.ts","apps/cli/src/cli/portfolio-policy.test.ts","apps/cli/src/cli/portfolio-preview.test.ts","apps/cli/src/cli/update-command.test.ts","apps/cli/src/content/finder-entrypoints-catalog-prompts.test.ts","apps/cli/src/content/improve-mobile-frontend.test.ts","apps/cli/src/content/scaffold-guidance.test.ts","apps/cli/src/content/verification-recovery-skills.test.ts","apps/cli/src/content/wiki.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/catalog/architect-pipeline-registration.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/catalog/make-tsuite-registration.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/catalog/verification-registration.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/generated-gate-scoping.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output-wiki-plugin-alias.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/project-verifier-preservation.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/settings-selection.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-authority.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-candidate.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-guidance-contract.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-recovery-publication.fixture.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-recovery-publication.runner.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-recovery-publication.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/release-verification-evidence.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/sync-skills-repo.test.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.test.ts","apps/cli/test-fixtures/portfolio/application.ts","apps/cli/test-fixtures/release-recovery/README.md","apps/cli/test-fixtures/release-recovery/build.mjs","apps/cli/test-fixtures/release-recovery/historical.fixture.ts","apps/cli/test-fixtures/release-recovery/historical.runner.ts","apps/cli/test-fixtures/update-prepared-seeds.ts","apps/cli/vitest.built.config.ts","apps/cli/vitest.release.config.ts","apps/cli/vitest.source.config.ts","apps/cli/vitest.update.config.ts","apps/web/package.json","apps/web/src/public-routes.test.tsx","apps/web/test-fixtures/public-routes.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/domains/ci-verification-and-publication-glossary.mdx","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/domains/index.mdx","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-217-ci-cost-grill-log.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-217-ci-cost-grill-status.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/issue-217-ci-cost-and-test-signal-research-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/ci-verification-and-publication.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/cli-specs.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/TEST-PORTFOLIO.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/VALIDATION.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/index.mdx","apps/wiki/package.json","apps/wiki/scripts/public-wiki-contract.test.ts","apps/wiki/scripts/source-page-tree.test.mjs","apps/wiki/scripts/sync-content.test.mjs","apps/wiki/src/public-routes.test.tsx","apps/wiki/test-fixtures/issue217/collections.mjs","apps/wiki/vitest.config.ts","behavior-contract/auth.json","behavior-contract/db.json","behavior-contract/ui.json","behavior-contract/web.json","docs/README.md","docs/runbooks/ci-verification-and-publication.md","docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","package.json","packages/auth/package.json","packages/auth/src/auth-email-contract.test.ts","packages/config/package.json","packages/config/public-config-contract.test.ts","packages/contract/package.json","packages/contract/src/api.test.ts","packages/db/package.json","packages/db/src/baseline-authority-postgres.test.ts","packages/db/src/postgres-contract.test.ts","packages/env/package.json","packages/scaffold/package.json","packages/scaffold/src/index.test.ts","packages/ui/package.json","packages/ui/src/public-ui-contract.test.tsx","scripts/behavior-contract/affected-verification.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/cache-identity.mjs","scripts/behavior-contract/cache-identity.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/cache-trust.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/ci-topology.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/consumer-repositories.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/isolation.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/issue-215-update-benchmark.mjs","scripts/behavior-contract/packaged-runtime-product.test.ts","scripts/behavior-contract/run-ci-verification.mjs","scripts/behavior-contract/run-turbo.mjs","scripts/behavior-contract/shared-cache-witness.mjs","scripts/behavior-contract/test-fixtures/valid-parked-web.json","scripts/behavior-contract/validate.mjs","scripts/behavior-contract/validate.test.ts","turbo.json"],"canonical_patch_hash":"eae8755700d09d09678df58a81b1ce492258b1a2b538e7d04860b0f651920f8b"},"snapshot_hash":"45b6e1f9c1a0a80ad550047b3c987c848f879d313cebc38b773111ab5a6e71d8","excluded_envelope":["apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-af60c94612b40a418623-20260922T110444Z-45b6e1f9c1a0-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/meta.json","apps/wiki/log.md"],"source_paths_and_hashes":[{"path":".agents/AGENTS.md","hash":"aeb2f6e427d67c64e78fba04b36fd5c90d1e2db03b39d6c23327a697304214da"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/api-contract-boundary.md","hash":"d667f914862c1dc241d84ef782234c2351c97b267bb3d108eb99276d267b91d5"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/backoffice-private-surface.md","hash":"a16bb1506e2aea6e1d69f8b86926ac250af045a84ab61da749cdfd62b5a84c57"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-local-boundary.md","hash":"0fb2217d2502a79602ed8ef3859624d0726ac4d8000e1a199588c65acee39d94"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-managed-asset-integrity.md","hash":"e1305365314ccf3b839df2be06b6c7b4afc4615953651678e12ae4840cdbc92d"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-release-contract.md","hash":"93ea0b85aa9b2227dc024b7427caab0dd9830594353fb888835a44a7f03200af"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-source-boundaries.md","hash":"99a15de2d60bf7492c7b1b3a23cce337874d48056c86d911c5eb4f1d6fa8f0e4"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/web-thin-surface.md","hash":"b821d79b9d783938adfae33a7d4cba919ea7d1f3e555814c6ffcb6594ec88d0d"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/wiki-content-schema.md","hash":"2416b98a8b4e9be19225d86d70838c4b6420e00cfdc1756bf4dd1dc2b126b073"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/wiki-route-tree.md","hash":"ff7a45d4af01eb921566fdc5f8d49f6315c3d12cd7d1109ff62fadb2e621650d"},{"path":".agents/rules/docs/knowledge-boundary.md","hash":"b9cb3406857850755f40a0a292fd6c7c48ea24c930aabb01d1dda48df0a0e38d"},{"path":".agents/rules/index.md","hash":"0b01f7dd1ba2f1504198da9f32acdaa0086fd7094b824cb4a7050260cd232d29"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/auth-ownership.md","hash":"be9ea7ca9713325d17631117c2564d264665ffc584cf561fbfaee99533545800"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/config-ownership.md","hash":"88b4666cb758fb6f3588c3561965fc56fe5ed6aa86864d023435582ce7bbce6d"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/contract-ownership.md","hash":"bbe78edd3e2b11306023fd10b9ce01221c75f9ba8cb50bc135d5604dfdf3a2d2"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/db-ownership.md","hash":"4fe221181fad4b122b7b292bb6329ed73cbae04cb976bb947efda5ff9e9f6c27"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/env-ownership.md","hash":"2bebe6c1c2e957c34115c83f2ff3e9da7e7ded6aa36559876b2cc39392b32bc7"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/scaffold-model-boundary.md","hash":"6fc3c28b2daf335ac618bc4439d3584d4ae44e2886f48bbc960681c5a68e710f"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/ui-ownership.md","hash":"3f4a91e98eef2a7b7fc01f37c178feef40c2bcb86a5d1bad0d2d6db83feec04a"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/baseline-release-entrypoint.md","hash":"e301ad62efc48069b1ce556ff9e4f80e2fa90893a3d7cfddc0b34babc5430ad1"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/cross-surface-contracts.md","hash":"1dcfa4ffe31d6ff77195881698700ff4da08f4f06cfb2228f48c729ad6a496c5"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/portless-local-urls.md","hash":"7116c77e0fd80bcbbe9df670f03bb51fe1c95302ae53f446c8a408e4661091e6"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/shared-skill-source.md","hash":"1524fb91e39045b9417408a46cd1efa08aabf54fe49bcc887bc3fb0531f6f1eb"},{"path":".agents/skills/architect-pipeline/SKILL.md","hash":"61bf73ab60eb3e38646a389a495db188501beaa610fd56681015ab74d8a29a08"},{"path":".agents/skills/autoreview/SKILL.md","hash":"c47ced5ce0e2dde47f6483ebf0b0854d3dac807b4bd7f1eb67edfce0573f3545"},{"path":".agents/skills/codebase-design/SKILL.md","hash":"a4b22a33f658d4cff395aed88eb6752dca8f929b57a2f129aba366236866a145"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"be24b5e3e5ba3facae3ca9af703597c2e7e5543ef2de0de7ac2f5ead0d8565e5"},{"path":".agents/skills/docs-ingest-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"bada2866deb5d6a314a7709aeeb39b64af3b0738b3211fedcc7561309126e97c"},{"path":".agents/skills/goalify/SKILL.md","hash":"0a7a747047fad6cc3983260bf408a5da8881e0d36337d9bb1167b5ebe7cdd6db"},{"path":".agents/skills/implement-spec/SKILL.md","hash":"efab4188e2d76a601d4a4f536b1ef64dba1d615a66b9b8da3243cacdb8812009"},{"path":".agents/skills/make-tsuite/SKILL.md","hash":"f233f2085ec164fdfe05a75fbab3ce991e741c7469a09545a9260c724a8b0c68"},{"path":".agents/skills/quality-types/SKILL.md","hash":"e85d2ae573b656a28ef83c1759c668a3cbd892ef8c17ff99bdf7b8149211cff5"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"60cc11940f099840c84107338da4f462f952503cffb4dfe3a52392b57f11a803"},{"path":".agents/skills/simplify/SKILL.md","hash":"60671f89002e2dc6c1b30961d82915907119c82c39e49c78bee102e554fb40bf"},{"path":".agents/skills/tdd/SKILL.md","hash":"4f527b87a5a46aff7cd006aee5252c0dc3d7204bc3b11d0a24d6c0e82716cdf2"},{"path":".agents/skills/turborepo/SKILL.md","hash":"0b3201f93b6e8304b05fb8832b73c4eb5c107239df46272a74851573c83a30c3"},{"path":"AGENTS.md","hash":"cf17d46def3ed1e69e72bb804a755e311bfdd6774adfd00204eb6ad6144dfcd3"},{"path":"apps/api/AGENTS.md","hash":"d2ff0466020f00a2ee269ed55a8cd3e25f95da89ec6af04fb1e2112dcaac6849"},{"path":"apps/backoffice/AGENTS.md","hash":"786ca61c2389b129ff42b0624945d9e4d0e2c20779a4471fa3a5c1b69d53b3c9"},{"path":"apps/cli/AGENTS.md","hash":"496e463f343080c274fef26718f00551dbf4873513aa308334b66295f9153057"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/AGENTS.md","hash":"6200edf9f9e7489ae1b6740c0e583ad8014e0faf9ff924faa0aa0c9e5a7c5692"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/data/AGENTS.md","hash":"d96e6710e332dd21042bd72da3323a17a40d15799143f70d83e7f824067e5ab2"},{"path":"apps/web/AGENTS.md","hash":"0271975d9a82b7d1510aec0e4b77f74376b85bbdd7162c4b3020bb3b474ed7b6"},{"path":"apps/wiki/AGENTS.md","hash":"f3bfa16772dbaec2cab4960ae6a1240854930a5c93aa5fd7e2ea77abf5889db3"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-217-ci-cost-grill-log.md","hash":"73fb696ee004d3de131f29b5f878eaa5b18f1e67aa78f90d949457ab4a783f35"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-217-ci-cost-grill-status.md","hash":"15c85ca8e300eb1f54ad875c75ce4903b5f13029a7a5021241445d0c57a0536a"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"ea0a85d36989ba8198d12f030566412ed0380b40c1c5354da7cf19dd60908aa8"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/PLAN.md","hash":"04473f3d6be20dfec7714c8e2ee3660fe23d7e44be8fa0cdfd1bb987efeac897"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/SPEC.md","hash":"4d5da952ab66a9b50a9b450ab8a347cf2cc720d6e79fa538d4b3e1c4ee4ee8e9"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/TEST-PORTFOLIO.md","hash":"d01f9fdeda7a5d1983f42d0a4befa81e2787add6b1ae043b5a7755d3d8001463"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-217-ci-efficiency/VALIDATION.md","hash":"ae7122e2f34b056709411faf046a095b2c6300dbf2c7d2611d55c5913c5d3567"},{"path":"docs/AGENTS.md","hash":"56ebac144eb2793bafc963f9ac8400b594dfa9854174e499f974ea70941bbf40"},{"path":"packages/auth/AGENTS.md","hash":"7f3ec5098b6c70633a0c30398d367c0bb22cf79c4654c1abddfbe01b029d2a66"},{"path":"packages/config/AGENTS.md","hash":"9f57e76964f413e77a7a21328e15f96fc7322aaa582ccf91d5502084f26b136e"},{"path":"packages/contract/AGENTS.md","hash":"5e3e09bdb8d374bd82cf8ecf3e973b3944247c138da50e50f33a67fa617517b7"},{"path":"packages/db/AGENTS.md","hash":"c27afb2e7071bcb33f315d09df76bb6e0ad4a1a4b31a39804acd0f696b756d40"},{"path":"packages/env/AGENTS.md","hash":"8fef2a95287e4d405ac15a8ea6b2013040ec67c2fa9146e84bb22400cd8e1402"},{"path":"packages/scaffold/AGENTS.md","hash":"e168f5b62a74dd0cac9ac770c4d3f827b196d057b1ab9b7feb2ab87fedd5ba81"},{"path":"packages/ui/AGENTS.md","hash":"9cd706cb733196b7b424c9ff244474cdb8b350c04358fa8d1b10a0318073d834"}],"source_set_hash":"b35ce858bd46ff27601d6dc091e181e71b8bc8b0ef2ecedb2e36fb06ae05d563","lens_outcomes":{"standards":"findings","skill_adherence":"clean","architecture":"clean","simplify":"clean","spec":"clean"},"findings":[{"id":"ci-cache-001","lens":"standards","severity":"medium","location":"turbo.json:588 (@punks/cli#test:update inputs)","impact":"A consumed monorepo fixture change can reuse stale updater test results, so the aggregate can accept proof from different fixture inputs.","evidence":"The frozen updater test copies apps/cli/test-fixtures/monorepo-root at src/update/run.test.ts:2512–2516. Direct parsing of both live/frozen turbo.json confirms the test:update input array omits test-fixtures/monorepo-root/**. No broader fixture glob or dependency includes those bytes.","action":"Add only the consumed monorepo-root fixture closure to test:update and extend the existing real Turbo input-perturbation test to demonstrate the miss. Prepare and validate the patch in an isolated snapshot while report retention is gated.","return_route":"implementation"}],"routing":{"primary":"implementation","secondary_architecture_follow_up":false},"validation":[{"command":"node /tmp/hi-217-local-proof/review/check-freshness.mjs","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"45b6e1f9c1a0a80ad550047b3c987c848f879d313cebc38b773111ab5a6e71d8","after_hash":"45b6e1f9c1a0a80ad550047b3c987c848f879d313cebc38b773111ab5a6e71d8","outcome":"passed","evidence":"All115 frozen target paths and59 governing source hashes remain unchanged before and after reviewer execution and parent adjudication."},{"command":"Read frozen/live turbo.json task input membership and src/update/run.test.ts monorepo-root consumer; no test execution in reviewed checkout.","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"45b6e1f9c1a0a80ad550047b3c987c848f879d313cebc38b773111ab5a6e71d8","after_hash":"45b6e1f9c1a0a80ad550047b3c987c848f879d313cebc38b773111ab5a6e71d8","outcome":"passed","evidence":"Both task input arrays omit consumed fixture directory; matches challenger evidence. Full local verification and limitations are in frozen VALIDATION.md. No hosted or historical replay run."}],"delivery_goal_identity":"github:wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence/issues/217:ci-efficiency-delivery","review_ordinal":1,"preceding_repair_ordinal":null,"review_epoch":{"protocol":"primary-challenger-v1","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","results":[{"reviewer_identity":"issue217-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"standards","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue217-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"skill_adherence","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue217-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"architecture","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue217-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"simplify","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue217-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"spec","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue217-challenger","role":"challenger","coverage":"Cache soundness and retained safety proof: actual task input closure, transitive source/runtime identity, affected selection, signed trust, output restoration, fixture isolation and release/install/receipt failure boundaries","packet_identity":"918da258d98343ed1a554c559e78ef9d08715809951b1b78d09a7c2c726d1a58","outcome":"findings","candidates":[{"location":"turbo.json:588-620","evidence_pointer":"Frozen target turbo.json:613-615 includes only update-prepared-seeds.ts, single-package/**, and cli-test-temp.ts for @punks/cli#test:update; frozen target apps/cli/src/update/run.test.ts:2512-2516 copies ../../test-fixtures/monorepo-root into a routine selected updater case.","impact":"Changes to test-fixtures/monorepo-root do not alter the cached test:update task hash. An affected run can select the CLI workspace yet restore a prior updater result instead of executing the catalog-repair/receipt-adjacent scenario that consumes those fixture bytes.","proposed_severity":"medium","proposed_return_route":"implementation","uncertainty":"The copied fixture is a direct runtime input of the selected test; no corresponding input glob is present in the task definition."}],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null}],"adjudications":[{"candidate_refs":["[\"issue217-challenger\",\"Cache soundness and retained safety proof: actual task input closure, transitive source/runtime identity, affected selection, signed trust, output restoration, fixture isolation and release/install/receipt failure boundaries\",0]"],"finding_id":"ci-cache-001","evidence":"Accepted after reading the frozen task input array and its selected real updater fixture consumer; direct JSON membership checks were false for both frozen and live arrays. This is a concrete cache correctness defect within accepted scope."}]}}