review-90b50961547f924dfba8 review report

{"review_lineage_id":"90b50961547f924dfba893f79d8d6246a1ac2a460f7849795d485e5f3ce6ae67","review_run_id":"721fc859ddcd50663360ab0b7bd022be3308f8a874a6f009602efc179caaf420","accepted_bounds_identity":"spec:apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/SPEC.md@sha256:1920f5920e08b465bf6f8a3f546750b5b256f52bc84b19d9886f1f076c13cc7b;user-bounds:sha256:094b455ae497478ac880cfa14cddceb0d466bd9cb4229e7bb941eacf79b4e645","accepted_bounds_hash":"2efd7b193adcaf92df0bff0fa5f463998fd1e838071cb205b2df908405cec68e","reviewed_at":"20260921T194550Z","mode":"delivery","normalized_target":{"kind":"delivery-git-diff","locator":"https://github.com/wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence/pull/222","actual_base_ref":"origin/main","fixed_point_sha":"7e147b3300c391db979b87e20c4159a5a03d12cb","head_identity":"14f1bb14b57fef634dbd10da5f5bb31598ed61a3","inclusive_scope":[".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/README.md",".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/README.md",".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/README.md",".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/candidate-update.md",".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/commit-coverage.md",".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/helpers/commit-coverage.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/bundled-baseline-identity.generated.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/sync-subagents-validator.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/sync-subagents.mjs","apps/cli/src/features/commit-gate/quality.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/commit-gate/quality.ts","apps/cli/src/features/context-planning/compiler.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/context-planning/compiler.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/index.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/model.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/service.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/service.ts","apps/cli/src/features/repository-analysis/model.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-state/generation-inputs.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-state/generation-inputs.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-update/validation-plan.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-update/validation-plan.ts","apps/cli/src/integrations/repository-detector.test.ts","apps/cli/src/integrations/repository-detector.ts","apps/cli/src/platform/scoped-scaffold-operation.test.ts","apps/cli/src/platform/scoped-scaffold-operation.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/scripts.test.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/scripts.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/validation-candidate.test.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/validation-candidate.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output-root-materialization.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.test.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.ts","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/open-issue-quick-fix-ranking-2026-09-21-research-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/cli-specs.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/meta.json","docs/README.md","docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","packages/scaffold/src/context-plan.test.ts","packages/scaffold/src/context-plan.ts"],"canonical_patch_hash":"a902d2130eb75a53b7a0889fd614ebab098cc7e2c0b9c01445ff48088e395575"},"snapshot_hash":"1d1b4ae3ad030d7b17c18d32b13f9e5b34ae20150749a28b1d2fd18492c6ac15","excluded_envelope":["apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-90b50961547f924dfba8-20260921T194550Z-1d1b4ae3ad03-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/meta.json","apps/wiki/log.md"],"source_paths_and_hashes":[{"path":"../evidence/review-preparation-entry-evidence.md","hash":"6b415cb0f6cb5aafa73cac8e268dae038de476d428d9b62295237fda78cc0532"},{"path":"../evidence/review-preparation-retained-inventory.md","hash":"59b3d2a0357a22e0e7ace068518d21f930d96d85e499254768bd0bacc17657e7"},{"path":"../evidence/review-preparation-skill-audit.md","hash":"aeee1d495e84d98b5979566233e62951d4ea401f4bbe4c563f68e698ed682fb9"},{"path":"../evidence/review-preparation-user-bounds.md","hash":"094b455ae497478ac880cfa14cddceb0d466bd9cb4229e7bb941eacf79b4e645"},{"path":".agents/AGENTS.md","hash":"aeb2f6e427d67c64e78fba04b36fd5c90d1e2db03b39d6c23327a697304214da"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-05-12T10-56-10-implement-spec-manual-checklist.md","hash":"67de02aa0337283cec45fb39a338614b8dcc098ee2d2f9a24a3e483ec71a7431"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-07-08-format-hook-managed-assets.md","hash":"42f8e36ff1fdc760be44ec7a2b7c8dd073c97e6bdab8109d89c2e5113ab39fe9"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-07-10-project-owned-wiki-sync.md","hash":"ca8ed61dc241fadfdc3ac34d4d09dc2114099604377cce9d61eae2920c7a1b7b"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-07-21-fumadocs-generated-source-order.md","hash":"ae00392469c4ddf5ed74da55723f5cef96eff4a5948b76e1f65679db58134e97"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-07-22-projection-and-provider-interruption.md","hash":"8ffdeb81d9817a8ea265aeab7c9a57b7b477ef2fb3bd51124417d4ef40a8ffae"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-08-04-scaffold-parent-identity.md","hash":"7184975b8761e8ba375a3e688fea7456bb0deb9ffaaa974da94672b3adcfc54f"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-08-10-scaffold-projection-health.md","hash":"13f69467dd7cc4fa1f5102446d63670cec6e1ada657f80f75fa6bb23eafaf50e"},{"path":".agents/notes/2026-08-20-effect-tsgo-oxlint-version-coupling.md","hash":"101b76e720fe8b41adeaff5dcd3dfbb9c3cdbc60bf7f2273a6ae01f3c12def6c"},{"path":".agents/notes/index.md","hash":"bc62798d27fa262112b6072a57d05498583e49b971acba4748c5dc185dc1f6c2"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-local-boundary.md","hash":"0fb2217d2502a79602ed8ef3859624d0726ac4d8000e1a199588c65acee39d94"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-managed-asset-integrity.md","hash":"e1305365314ccf3b839df2be06b6c7b4afc4615953651678e12ae4840cdbc92d"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-release-contract.md","hash":"93ea0b85aa9b2227dc024b7427caab0dd9830594353fb888835a44a7f03200af"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-source-boundaries.md","hash":"99a15de2d60bf7492c7b1b3a23cce337874d48056c86d911c5eb4f1d6fa8f0e4"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/wiki-content-schema.md","hash":"2416b98a8b4e9be19225d86d70838c4b6420e00cfdc1756bf4dd1dc2b126b073"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/wiki-route-tree.md","hash":"ff7a45d4af01eb921566fdc5f8d49f6315c3d12cd7d1109ff62fadb2e621650d"},{"path":".agents/rules/docs/knowledge-boundary.md","hash":"b9cb3406857850755f40a0a292fd6c7c48ea24c930aabb01d1dda48df0a0e38d"},{"path":".agents/rules/index.md","hash":"0b01f7dd1ba2f1504198da9f32acdaa0086fd7094b824cb4a7050260cd232d29"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/scaffold-model-boundary.md","hash":"6fc3c28b2daf335ac618bc4439d3584d4ae44e2886f48bbc960681c5a68e710f"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/ui-ownership.md","hash":"3f4a91e98eef2a7b7fc01f37c178feef40c2bcb86a5d1bad0d2d6db83feec04a"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/baseline-release-entrypoint.md","hash":"e301ad62efc48069b1ce556ff9e4f80e2fa90893a3d7cfddc0b34babc5430ad1"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/cross-surface-contracts.md","hash":"1dcfa4ffe31d6ff77195881698700ff4da08f4f06cfb2228f48c729ad6a496c5"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/portless-local-urls.md","hash":"7116c77e0fd80bcbbe9df670f03bb51fe1c95302ae53f446c8a408e4661091e6"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/shared-skill-source.md","hash":"1524fb91e39045b9417408a46cd1efa08aabf54fe49bcc887bc3fb0531f6f1eb"},{"path":".agents/skills/autoreview/SKILL.md","hash":"ed92db2290d36fc30b39503845e23ece7605ad9ed6c0bbdb78034587690ab890"},{"path":".agents/skills/autoreview/scripts/autoreview","hash":"f05c07ffd4fe29ff9513bc1fccf4258bd35ae6deed56380e6a67127bcc2219f8"},{"path":".agents/skills/brainstorm/SKILL.md","hash":"9b8f3a6aaa568c1cb587172c41102824d1489562b06d35a1d1cb4c5a90ecd6de"},{"path":".agents/skills/codebase-design/SKILL.md","hash":"a4b22a33f658d4cff395aed88eb6752dca8f929b57a2f129aba366236866a145"},{"path":".agents/skills/create-plan/SKILL.md","hash":"0bdaf2c219d6de9f021c67131505954e814b2aa6a41bd7f262599ee2f094fcdf"},{"path":".agents/skills/create-spec/SKILL.md","hash":"9b14c67ccf5ee3222fc691b1422a9ce07355476752bdfcb663329b1150725493"},{"path":".agents/skills/create-verification-skill/references/upstream.md","hash":"f67927ffeaaaef577d0a35f87c851fd2c0dec5c1b28fc68658198140aba1c9c5"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"8b369712d91a337fb2ad8cf6095c853e383a6152d1c5602130d162fd1f0b6232"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/phases/implement.md","hash":"2349bd10f3250ceed23b15766f0254f857eb60b0d2859a0c9075795eb7f406ad"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/phases/review.md","hash":"207880f0a7702a3ff06934973deca6ec44384d875cc8df75919e9e2e052102bc"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/phases/router.md","hash":"460ab98f9b45ebd07dc454164164b65bee12178b38c51f31c67a8842a8638791"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/references/phase-handoff.md","hash":"b8c8d973c09736df5537a8458302bf22cc3361ff7ec6c4c08fbd9dfb37f53f27"},{"path":".agents/skills/effect-service-design/SKILL.md","hash":"9718b98d9f2ef1aab69be0eb2d0c36ac7174b75d1afe8fd9bfb4db329ee9f5ca"},{"path":".agents/skills/effect/SKILL.md","hash":"c0467cf7bcdb9284bb09af8cfab2475419ea46be26b42272c22549caf7e27d90"},{"path":".agents/skills/effect/references/SCHEMA.md","hash":"a79b7f58bc6a2e8cf33d8f44b00094177acf97b8e322470c5033e57e4024b773"},{"path":".agents/skills/effect/references/SERVICES_LAYERS.md","hash":"c8411288a141fbe25e2e9003a1765f69587753d9c6b94ba1ae31c03d481d8be5"},{"path":".agents/skills/effect/references/TESTING.md","hash":"f9aaeda704ed7418ca2ee99c9684e0dae5eeb685d73db190a048bcf5566b2b56"},{"path":".agents/skills/goalify/SKILL.md","hash":"0a7a747047fad6cc3983260bf408a5da8881e0d36337d9bb1167b5ebe7cdd6db"},{"path":".agents/skills/implement-spec/SKILL.md","hash":"efab4188e2d76a601d4a4f536b1ef64dba1d615a66b9b8da3243cacdb8812009"},{"path":".agents/skills/improve-codebase-architecture/SKILL.md","hash":"d4372c3704c92e0b49767ca7202bf1d6238e9f42b4f5dfd2173fce10cd803061"},{"path":".agents/skills/parallel-research/SKILL.md","hash":"6dba46128bda64ee21511daba9a7725c2987944dda97a9bf7ba710d0d8c4e02a"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"60cc11940f099840c84107338da4f462f952503cffb4dfe3a52392b57f11a803"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/phases/prepare-review.md","hash":"2f45fa6ce6dc807105fecb7fa15e86e7d18d8b2ab54ba2f0fdb13554271d0462"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/phases/retain-report.md","hash":"bc916ae5defa27cf78cb53bec62743fc71f064b537842389d6f2b1fd57ebc82d"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/phases/return-route.md","hash":"cb3479a646b50cf88b2a950cb69c8e20a6f778425ada36cc644c764584695e5f"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/phases/router.md","hash":"de2507c6ab88a178af31abab8dc779250520e1f80cab6bf1c8dfd8e0d2a44d07"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/phases/run-review.md","hash":"583144ca23e55614cb5453ba86be367cb162c9df0f8e74e95eee66756ee1bed2"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/references/durable-report.md","hash":"f634461c3c73a7ded6231293328c723d6fbde59ade938408c623387289a50c03"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/references/review-packet.md","hash":"aaa407550c51afe6442a1850e9c4424e0cedd5842969e73b7bbda1dc3c9167ea"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/references/runtime-handoff.md","hash":"fd41efacff556e3c8fb8f95f3b465214711f1116292e2de6784b7872fe109df0"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/references/state-graph.md","hash":"fb0584fe1382a00f285e96de1810f6dc2c408919cd0db96b154907b3ae926593"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/references/targets.md","hash":"a07ce7314ab4ed6d410134c70371bb110856f8a4da0f890529460184b8da28e3"},{"path":".agents/skills/review-phase/scripts/review-contract.mjs","hash":"729c21ce935a6398bdaf33ef5282464f62741a184178b231e75805830a61c35e"},{"path":".agents/skills/show-me/SKILL.md","hash":"acc4988102c4ee83d9169b9c54148844789a83eb7af0d8440f8ad753dde61d96"},{"path":".agents/skills/simplify/SKILL.md","hash":"60671f89002e2dc6c1b30961d82915907119c82c39e49c78bee102e554fb40bf"},{"path":".agents/skills/tdd/SKILL.md","hash":"4f527b87a5a46aff7cd006aee5252c0dc3d7204bc3b11d0a24d6c0e82716cdf2"},{"path":".agents/skills/tdd/high-signal-tests.md","hash":"aece0653a9a0273d1684ac763726c9241cae496dea37d10797d1eee04c03dc26"},{"path":".agents/skills/update-verification-skill/SKILL.md","hash":"8a8ccbca137897497a080d2a4b62b01db78eba0d2725a7cf15a99f65275538f4"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/SKILL.md","hash":"8599fa2c20058d08515cc47dde342c7501daf48a673d18b6515d0ad7748b8fcf"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/README.md","hash":"1079634a3e77aec18aaf3f98c4d937003560af2a324c6b3d7ee72107939ec2f4"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/README.md","hash":"995cf21df33b472f0a2a735b2943d66ce5c7d9ae67d75f6070b24723ac380a93"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/README.md","hash":"b02578a52a22caf5679a6951062274b4e679bc14183ce22764026c51e8fd2e11"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/candidate-update.md","hash":"a0aab9cfd3f1158c861ba36d85d73343a9003580891c327bd46780e6ca84ff35"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/command-discovery.md","hash":"0bef675763adac003ff8c63807bfa328bcf10eee48e0ce52c8a21ad0202181b2"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/features/commit-coverage.md","hash":"32fbe5ace08fa62ff10ccbffa9ff14c7ce9dad5ff118f78c0da1969ad70f78a9"},{"path":".agents/skills/verify-behavior/references/cli/helpers/commit-coverage.mjs","hash":"c964701773c519b71f4d74736034f7d5f59aa7e48b273a6526c9806e0a8e084c"},{"path":".agents/skills/writing-for-agents/SKILL.md","hash":"a842323e664e5af104eac5c97ad22fda929ebeb62d81c501161ac1f6f482db58"},{"path":".agents/subagents/manifest.mjs","hash":"cfec146a4fb0742f09ff8e3d1f0bd60b0d4c5f843edd791f3bc5b6c6278e627c"},{"path":"AGENTS.md","hash":"f3c1f0406c086917182100fd51b5e84793b4a7ff39aad08cd33dbf14b4e2cbcc"},{"path":"apps/cli/AGENTS.md","hash":"46d1cf36f2270a84c004a4a7f826913ee602b1bdf62ce2b93895db1f0c62f1b1"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/AGENTS.md","hash":"861835a958c73dcc59df6e1f6decf1f8f562b1a6899d35b77e02509ce43b25b5"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/data/AGENTS.md","hash":"d4cc52b74bed795c3196bc015b4b9ef717248ec2a74858bfbca772daa2819969"},{"path":"apps/wiki/AGENTS.md","hash":"52450b18b2ffe4e1976f70d31f0bd7a08b79689610281c0919bd1f701914a46f"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/open-issue-quick-fix-ranking-2026-09-21-research-report.md","hash":"a18cd263148bb29592705b62e9a9f10d42fc322ccc076d0721374f8658fc9f96"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","hash":"9abcb4fc79c0fe4ae9d2db4cd57208ae939907f0890b684a4abeabf6620d5743"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"97342fdae1365be05c7cf902cf9fe300c993ef230178a9a43574179f08c1c9c8"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/PLAN.md","hash":"5223d51207578a80533f7d5b084c7537010ea82ab35b8f826935b4243cbe688f"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/SPEC.md","hash":"1920f5920e08b465bf6f8a3f546750b5b256f52bc84b19d9886f1f076c13cc7b"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-200-201-219-220-validation/meta.json","hash":"00f385c8bf4e9857627cd566976e3bf3cdeec2c0f05b44cebe6f2e5c190c5e3e"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/meta.json","hash":"b21b9b2d5bcf524d949742c82375f9fb5a78b50de6caf88d6cc19832d9dd4cb8"},{"path":"apps/wiki/scripts/sync-content.mjs","hash":"1d169fd5fc3bca20d48336ce100d78de6fedab26942447aa23e19410d4d3dafd"},{"path":"apps/wiki/source.config.ts","hash":"15897aeee4549806e5be02408729bbe61ada98e1bb7e2d2a2b5ec9d401387d48"},{"path":"docs/AGENTS.md","hash":"d91a598485faad6c010d026c58ddd84777d637eea0f3a548118fb72cee26cf33"},{"path":"docs/README.md","hash":"2f29c04fcfdb73ca9c99f01941886cd03969979a4b22e2323642378b1aa3a99a"},{"path":"docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","hash":"9abcb4fc79c0fe4ae9d2db4cd57208ae939907f0890b684a4abeabf6620d5743"},{"path":"opensrc/README.md","hash":"9d2e131285214eb50b63d4c210fe7f06bc5be9dbd17a1551be2f0c8234cca3fd"},{"path":"opensrc/effect.md","hash":"6c348f5f8ffe675ff140c16d6a10af5d823a93a0b55e0325422a49de725daeaa"},{"path":"packages/scaffold/AGENTS.md","hash":"e7fbf9dafa1db843d05440c885b173edefe11488ab430678b1b2b8fb09645dd7"}],"source_set_hash":"b2e35000c1a9a9662701e6a3327a032c24ce552beeacceb3d0ebacb2ba5b0abc","lens_outcomes":{"standards":"clean","skill_adherence":"clean","architecture":"clean","simplify":"clean","spec":"findings"},"findings":[{"id":"pr222-r1","lens":"spec","severity":"medium","location":"apps/cli/src/update/run.ts:6168","impact":"Affected-owner selection can skip a lint-enabled consumer that declares the changed shared package in optionalDependencies.","evidence":"Parent inspected frozen update/run.ts:6168-6176 and repository-detector.ts:148-151. Caller combines dependencies/devDependencies/peerDependencies but omits optionalDependencies; detector includes optionalDependencies. validation-plan.ts:129-138 follows only supplied dependency edges. A lint consumer depending optionally on a changed shared package is therefore missed. SPEC AC-004 covers consuming scopes without this exclusion. Accept as medium correctness repair within existing scope; no public schema/ownership/runtime topology change.","action":"Include optionalDependencies in caller dependency-edge construction and add a public update regression proving that consumer is selected. Run focused checks and actual affected CLI proof.","return_route":"implementation"}],"routing":{"primary":"implementation","secondary_architecture_follow_up":false},"validation":[{"command":"node ../evidence/review-preparation-helper.mjs verify ../evidence/review-preparation-run1; git diff --check 7e147b3300c391db979b87e20c4159a5a03d12cb HEAD","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"1d1b4ae3ad030d7b17c18d32b13f9e5b34ae20150749a28b1d2fd18492c6ac15","after_hash":"1d1b4ae3ad030d7b17c18d32b13f9e5b34ae20150749a28b1d2fd18492c6ac15","outcome":"passed","evidence":"../evidence/review-preparation-run1/final-freshness.json; candidate-verification.md; exact frozen source line inspection."}],"delivery_goal_identity":"codex:01a0c406-f179-7833-8c73-f770c5cfa144:issues-200-201-219-220","review_ordinal":1,"preceding_repair_ordinal":null,"review_epoch":{"protocol":"primary-challenger-v1","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","results":[{"reviewer_identity":"pr222-primary-1","role":"primary","coverage":"standards","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"pr222-primary-1","role":"primary","coverage":"skill_adherence","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"pr222-primary-1","role":"primary","coverage":"architecture","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"pr222-primary-1","role":"primary","coverage":"simplify","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"pr222-primary-1","role":"primary","coverage":"spec","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"pr222-candidate-boundary-1","role":"challenger","coverage":"Candidate publication boundaries: affected-owner selection, owning dependency installations, final composed symlink/config closure, guidance-only integrity checks, and negative no-publication behavior","packet_identity":"02122a47e0d2f36c65f7009c611eedc5e63e5be2e78512fe23562090bdb23afa","outcome":"findings","candidates":[{"location":"apps/cli/src/update/run.ts:6168","evidence_pointer":"Frozen head 14f1bb14b57fef634dbd10da5f5bb31598ed61a3: run.ts:6168-6176 builds consumer edges without optionalDependencies, while repository-detector.ts:148-151 includes optionalDependencies in package dependency discovery; SPEC AC-004 requires consuming scopes validation.","impact":"A changed shared config/dependency can publish after validating only its owner while skipping a lint-enabled consumer that declares the shared package as optional, leaving that consumer outside affected-owner selection.","proposed_severity":"medium","proposed_return_route":"implementation","uncertainty":"This assumes optional dependencies are valid consuming edges; the shipped detector treats them as dependencies and the accepted bounds state no optional-edge exclusion."}],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null}],"adjudications":[{"candidate_refs":["[\"pr222-candidate-boundary-1\",\"Candidate publication boundaries: affected-owner selection, owning dependency installations, final composed symlink/config closure, guidance-only integrity checks, and negative no-publication behavior\",0]"],"finding_id":"pr222-r1","evidence":"Parent inspected frozen update/run.ts:6168-6176 and repository-detector.ts:148-151. Caller combines dependencies/devDependencies/peerDependencies but omits optionalDependencies; detector includes optionalDependencies. validation-plan.ts:129-138 follows only supplied dependency edges. A lint consumer depending optionally on a changed shared package is therefore missed. SPEC AC-004 covers consuming scopes without this exclusion. Accept as medium correctness repair within existing scope; no public schema/ownership/runtime topology change."}]}}