review-5fa610b53dcfcb3beacc review report

{"review_lineage_id":"5fa610b53dcfcb3beacc7b4308b800f65c4500288e2f2f173c9fd0a83df4a252","review_run_id":"448b623ae6e06e1e627b49edc800fda61e6c1f812a2f0b2acaf6dbc312ead61f","accepted_bounds_identity":"user:2026-09-15:release-stack-203-207-main-ready","accepted_bounds_hash":"bb7c38ca43bede3e6df4f9c08c44033194a8094dd2e78e5427240e69b95b7321","reviewed_at":"20260915T163900Z","mode":"delivery","normalized_target":{"kind":"delivery-git-diff","locator":"https://github.com/wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence/pull/214","actual_base_ref":"origin/main","fixed_point_sha":"4e9ff3390e3a2d9d69d5b482793259d51ce85669","head_identity":"7251dea889b5879dc783dd80391dce17c9ed4b76","inclusive_scope":[".agents/notes/2026-08-10-scaffold-projection-health.md",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/README.md",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/baseline-comparison.json",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/closeout.json",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/lint-loading.json",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/review.json",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/validation.json",".devpunks/delivery/issue-203/verification.json","BASELINE_CHANGELOG.md","CHANGELOG.md","apps/cli/package.json","apps/cli/scripts/sync-skills-repo.mjs","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/planning/verify-behavior/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/planning/verify-behavior/agents/openai.yaml","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/quality/tdd/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-backend-structure/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-backend-structure/references/layout.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/effect/effect-service-design/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/react/react-doctor/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/frameworks/react/react-doctor/references/explain.md","apps/cli/src/content/verification-recovery-skills.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/bundled-baseline-identity.generated.ts","apps/cli/src/data/catalog/packs.ts","apps/cli/src/data/catalog/skills.ts","apps/cli/src/data/catalog/verification-registration.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.d.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-state/obligation.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output-root-materialization.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output-wiki-plugin-alias.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/project-verifier-preservation.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/stage.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/sync-skills-repo.test.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.test.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.ts","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-204-portable-commit-gates-grill-log.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-204-portable-commit-gates-grill-status.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/issue-203-scaffold-convergence-research-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/issue-204-portable-commit-gates-research-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-16f4c152b338e7d2c40c-20260915T124416Z-5da981e73e6d-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-16f4c152b338e7d2c40c-20260915T132152Z-afe5b389c8f8-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-16f4c152b338e7d2c40c-20260915T132848Z-0e174ed78df3-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-18f689275d3b9d826478-20260915T123330Z-2f2be78ca22b-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-18f689275d3b9d826478-20260915T124905Z-1c75709fa6b3-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-18f689275d3b9d826478-20260915T140148Z-8fbaee5b1080-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-eaaed7e52a7a55b113d0-20260915T093941Z-3857ebf5c8ac-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-eaaed7e52a7a55b113d0-20260915T094816Z-ddc6fe9dd605-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/.source-projection.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/cli-specs.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/PHASE-HANDOFF.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/meta.json","apps/wiki/index.md","apps/wiki/log.md","apps/wiki/source.config.ts","apps/wiki/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/meta.json","bun.lock","docs/README.md","docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","packages/scaffold/src/baseline/obligation.ts"],"canonical_patch_hash":"17c123aeaef7c266229baaf5dbe1ab5edcb601662d3b41ce1a7bf2e8d9576724"},"snapshot_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","excluded_envelope":["apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-5fa610b53dcfcb3beacc-20260915T163900Z-afca554e4fd5-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/meta.json","apps/wiki/log.md"],"source_paths_and_hashes":[{"path":".agents/skills/autoreview/SKILL.md","hash":"6a8c9ecf8aedcd38eee39fb2d3c60823cadc5ee6296f23482ea5bd253f43d3d8"},{"path":".agents/skills/codebase-design/SKILL.md","hash":"a4b22a33f658d4cff395aed88eb6752dca8f929b57a2f129aba366236866a145"},{"path":".agents/skills/delivery-phase/SKILL.md","hash":"cfb5932046f96009a9cebf11d4e5cf36fabd9d4c0f3c8b7333870388a7ab4d59"},{"path":".agents/skills/goalify/SKILL.md","hash":"0a7a747047fad6cc3983260bf408a5da8881e0d36337d9bb1167b5ebe7cdd6db"},{"path":".agents/skills/quality-types/SKILL.md","hash":"ab9c9c42279fc9a3704e459460b41e4486a9628ae31297fbeba346e3a6840703"},{"path":".agents/skills/review/SKILL.md","hash":"028b2084af14fe8ebfdd62710b74b873a5505a0148ba1b264a90296f4b084797"},{"path":".agents/skills/show-me/SKILL.md","hash":"acc4988102c4ee83d9169b9c54148844789a83eb7af0d8440f8ad753dde61d96"},{"path":".agents/skills/simplify/SKILL.md","hash":"60671f89002e2dc6c1b30961d82915907119c82c39e49c78bee102e554fb40bf"},{"path":".agents/skills/tdd/SKILL.md","hash":"1e72cad2cc455bd77e3da51d9448f45b40a9f0f3b74f00424b209233c5744b1c"},{"path":".agents/skills/writing-for-agents/SKILL.md","hash":"a842323e664e5af104eac5c97ad22fda929ebeb62d81c501161ac1f6f482db58"},{"path":".devpunks/delivery/issue-207/INTEGRATION-REVIEW.md","hash":"97bb10c58f86750da7c5fb6f066bbb0e34291d630517f933b9209f203d5f0f2b"},{"path":"AGENTS.md","hash":"9e44b149270d3405ea72734691b84dc999db0a12e8838acb26845ec1ce950a07"},{"path":"apps/cli/AGENTS.md","hash":"8ddeed635076e050608ee20d71f1c6dc1b8c4b2aa3faea33a05e3ebf99b2c9a1"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/AGENTS.md","hash":"9a5033a9c2e4d77a84402117635c589c9ac56e14a00d9a6dede5f788df5bda53"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/data/AGENTS.md","hash":"5db590543bc6b9dfb84f1ea1ecea2ec37bcc39e11a1a2514719aef4e848609ab"},{"path":"apps/wiki/AGENTS.md","hash":"998467e95c421760bafe60ba51ff07fbb2f75961b7fac4c4ed3106ea7f3ee14d"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"5f0e1df0a5aa96cc373d39197159d2d0c1261ae397e906c72f4a4bfac878ba23"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/PLAN.md","hash":"3a45cb4f518e03a25977612388d74d791926c7f3478a331ec0205cdb965d2c24"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/SPEC.md","hash":"d43bc8b993c8f937511830831f5414a0816e621ac026d2f9feb6c7c5245648bf"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"4cd20409391a0373e2d744198b0763c7c49ca286b0cb1227b1ca3c3009c5c2c8"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/PLAN.md","hash":"28f8d78ca32bb75da672213ee8c053b7c374441ecca99a59be9b7744923db495"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-204-portable-commit-gates/SPEC.md","hash":"b29d7689788c968e677b79348fceb9c42987a69c4737b0d5e47bae69e672a0c2"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"e6db7ec01e15b01b160daa65ca076d3a77602e9451b2899d071d6cc02006e303"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/PLAN.md","hash":"ad3bc64f24a8f469a5f46b555ed9da7ef39d35d3ad4dafe01b97825363b2530f"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/SPEC.md","hash":"8e0777648813813acd0359e9d3d5a371665cad5599a1a32aa2b404eaa4ed05f1"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"5422633292c2740078980cd6fd53704504df23786955734fe63993a32c2a2e1d"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/PLAN.md","hash":"f60b7ebf68f4e29e71baa065af0261fa9ba3c80b042ed136b66c5bbdd0b26954"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-206-skill-activation-boundaries/SPEC.md","hash":"47387bd9c17af1c0309075d49175a98069326e031dcd3445de26fec544395224"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"75562a2bb250b148f7e7d9297fbf228debc3c9f009acfed5dbae8ff3cf2d877d"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/PLAN.md","hash":"8c76ea78a80f615fdeb7c9cc1c46f2c05c24972ca4f5f10452e0963f30fbb769"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-207-verification-recovery-skills/SPEC.md","hash":"cbee87a7db4efd24c0656cb8c359bdd1b0d304b090ad1760d6172207c7641386"},{"path":"docs/AGENTS.md","hash":"599c64fde205da1e408469956bbf0da58994aec533bbb8291b206b65c64121e1"},{"path":"packages/scaffold/AGENTS.md","hash":"739f6860d070f89b98275c5cce34ef06b8d64647e22616f23a69374fd9232992"}],"source_set_hash":"9bad2a568c57c7ebc4c528b4a03e9be64a5cda28645b1c605a1298c43fba0429","lens_outcomes":{"standards":"findings","skill_adherence":"clean","architecture":"clean","simplify":"clean","spec":"findings"},"findings":[{"id":"ri-std-001","lens":"standards","severity":"medium","location":"docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md:227; apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md:233","impact":"Current runbooks direct private bindings into a composition directory forbidden by the shipped Effect structure guidance.","evidence":"Frozen layout.md:44 requires services/<capability>/binding.ts. Both current runbooks still prescribe composition/<capability>/service.ts. Root/docs guidance requires documentation to match implemented architecture.","action":"Align the current runbook's private binding path and regenerate its wiki mirror; preserve historical report bytes.","return_route":"docs_ingest"},{"id":"ri-spec-001","lens":"spec","severity":"medium","location":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-205-effect-backend-internal-modules/SPEC.md:43","impact":"The retained current acceptance contract still names the original composition path after the user-triggered #205 review repair chose a private binding alongside its public service.","evidence":"AC-001 prescribes composition/<capability>/service.ts, whereas the preserved user-feedback implementation at 1e9e6f63 / restacked 4e3e7cef and canonical source 0519d685 require services/<capability>/binding.ts. Later user diff comments explicitly requested resolving the contradictory placement.","action":"Record the accepted review-feedback reconciliation in current spec/notes, preserving original context and immutable review reports; do not roll back canonical guidance.","return_route":"docs_ingest"},{"id":"ri-std-002","lens":"standards","severity":"medium","location":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/meta.json","impact":"Six retained #204/#207 reports are absent from explicit review navigation after stack integration, making their evidence undiscoverable through the page tree.","evidence":"Readonly directory-to-meta comparison found only four navigation entries and six missing existing review-report slugs. Wiki AGENTS.md requires new routed pages to be registered in metadata.","action":"Restore all existing review-report slugs in review navigation without modifying any historical report bytes.","return_route":"docs_ingest"}],"routing":{"primary":"docs_ingest","secondary_architecture_follow_up":false},"validation":[{"command":"Readonly frozen diff/source inspection by five bounded lens workers and parent; direct JSON scope count and canonical patch SHA-256 comparison","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","after_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","outcome":"passed","evidence":"89 inclusive paths verified on disk; compressed tool output had misleadingly shown an excerpt. Canonical patch hash and head remain unchanged. Source-first provenance and eight-entry implementation skill-guidance cardinality verified. Architecture and simplify found no concrete regressions."},{"command":"autoreview --mode branch --base 4e9ff3390e3a2d9d69d5b482793259d51ce85669 --engine codex --model gpt-6-astra --thinking xhigh --prompt-file .devpunks/delivery/issue-207/INTEGRATION-REVIEW.md","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","after_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","outcome":"failed","evidence":"One advisory invocation returned the same binding-path candidate; helper rejected its absolute file path. No valid helper result or clean helper claim retained. Independent Standards/Spec lenses and parent directly verified the candidate from frozen code; their accepted findings are recorded above. No reviewer rerun performed."},{"command":"git diff --quiet origin/main 7251dea8 -- apps/cli/src/cli/operator-command.ts apps/cli/src/features/operator-skill apps/cli/src/integrations/skills-cli.ts apps/cli/src/integrations/skills-cli-target-delegation.test.ts; canonical source/cache/receipt comparisons; review navigation inventory","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","after_hash":"afca554e4fd5317205125089551b727615b15c8f016985d2e6e2c46335b3ca8a","outcome":"passed","evidence":"Operator runtime/tests equal main; canonical skills, remote annotated tag, cache and receipt agree at 0519d685. Six historical reports absent from explicit navigation. Required combined hosted CI is pending and is not claimed as passing."}],"delivery_goal_identity":"release-issues-203-207-main-ready","review_ordinal":1,"preceding_repair_ordinal":null}