review-9b0b6d833f6dd09c7004 review report

{"review_lineage_id":"9b0b6d833f6dd09c7004486be73893177aa15c193607caed4bf49abc2f74eb9e","review_run_id":"8897b899e0145b650876cbf55b83e0d235c9425c2e76c2a5572c63f9c455accd","accepted_bounds_identity":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/SPEC.md","accepted_bounds_hash":"13fbb0d1c81f9e464443ad62c8894ed377a74ebfbd2f67bb0fc5b92c191e2c7a","reviewed_at":"20260922T233841Z","mode":"delivery","normalized_target":{"kind":"delivery-git-diff","locator":"https://github.com/wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence/pull/225","actual_base_ref":"origin/main","fixed_point_sha":"71e84184be2e0eff48cffae43face01df5d300ab","head_identity":"eb514ee0dc316e88eafbc30f24ba062f9560f3a9:worktree:5a7b019dd660c907a18fe4bea5574161d1a3ee6f7ac6363e9e0f1aa37e51ff81","inclusive_scope":["apps/cli/scripts/assert-package-surface.mjs","apps/cli/scripts/sync-skills-repo.mjs","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/cli/hi-cli/SKILL.md","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/cli/hi-cli/references/commands.md","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/cli/hi-cli/references/managed-lint.md","apps/cli/skills/agnostic/cli/hi-cli/references/post-command-flow.md","apps/cli/src/cli/ensure-command.test.ts","apps/cli/src/cli/ensure-command.ts","apps/cli/src/content/wiki.ts","apps/cli/src/data/bundled-baseline-identity.generated.ts","apps/cli/src/data/hooks/format-edited-file.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/hooks/format-edited-file.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.d.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/commit-gate-runner.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/managed-lint-runner.d.mts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/managed-lint-runner.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/managed-lint-runner.test.ts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/managed-lint.d.mts","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/managed-lint.mjs","apps/cli/src/data/scripts/managed-lint.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/context-planning/managed-lint-ci-evidence.ts","apps/cli/src/features/context-planning/managed-lint-evidence.ts","apps/cli/src/features/managed-lint-policy/index.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/managed-lint-policy/index.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/index.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/model.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/service.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/project-settings/service.ts","apps/cli/src/features/repository-check/application.ts","apps/cli/src/features/repository-check/managed-lint-health.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/repository-check/managed-lint-health.ts","apps/cli/src/features/repository-check/port.ts","apps/cli/src/features/repository-scaffolding/interaction.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-operation/model.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-state/generation-inputs.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-state/generation-inputs.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-update/validation-plan.test.ts","apps/cli/src/features/scaffold-update/validation-plan.ts","apps/cli/src/managed-lint-contract.test.ts","apps/cli/src/platform/repository-check-capabilities.ts","apps/cli/src/presentation/operation-result/repository-check-facts.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/scripts.test.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/scripts.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/validation-candidate.test.ts","apps/cli/src/runtime/validation-candidate.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/managed-lint-generation.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/managed-lint-generation.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output-root-materialization.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/output.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/settings-selection.test.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/settings-selection.ts","apps/cli/src/scaffold/stage.ts","apps/cli/src/scripts/build-dist.test.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.test.ts","apps/cli/src/update/run.ts","apps/cli/tsconfig.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/domains/index.mdx","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/domains/issue-224-managed-lint-glossary.mdx","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/domains/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-224-managed-lint-grill-log.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-224-managed-lint-grill-status.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/issue-224-lint-boundaries-research-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/issue-224-oxlint-authority-research-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/research/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/cli-specs.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-181-lint-feedback-adoption/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-203-scaffold-convergence/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-215-manifest-driven-update/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/PLAN.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/meta.json","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/scaffold-lint-config-baseline/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/index.mdx","apps/wiki/index.md","apps/wiki/log.md","apps/wiki/specs/cli/issue-181-lint-feedback-adoption/SPEC.md","apps/wiki/specs/cli/scaffold-lint-config-baseline/SPEC.md","docs/README.md","docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md"],"canonical_patch_hash":"5a7b019dd660c907a18fe4bea5574161d1a3ee6f7ac6363e9e0f1aa37e51ff81"},"snapshot_hash":"06a24e9666e4fdfc722182befd69ea46855ade1a56ca23f325fc452366bb4bbd","excluded_envelope":["apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-9b0b6d833f6dd09c7004-20260922T233841Z-06a24e9666e4-review-report.md","apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/meta.json","apps/wiki/log.md"],"source_paths_and_hashes":[{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-local-boundary.md","hash":"0fb2217d2502a79602ed8ef3859624d0726ac4d8000e1a199588c65acee39d94"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-managed-asset-integrity.md","hash":"e1305365314ccf3b839df2be06b6c7b4afc4615953651678e12ae4840cdbc92d"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/cli-source-boundaries.md","hash":"99a15de2d60bf7492c7b1b3a23cce337874d48056c86d911c5eb4f1d6fa8f0e4"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/wiki-content-schema.md","hash":"2416b98a8b4e9be19225d86d70838c4b6420e00cfdc1756bf4dd1dc2b126b073"},{"path":".agents/rules/apps/wiki-route-tree.md","hash":"ff7a45d4af01eb921566fdc5f8d49f6315c3d12cd7d1109ff62fadb2e621650d"},{"path":".agents/rules/docs/knowledge-boundary.md","hash":"b9cb3406857850755f40a0a292fd6c7c48ea24c930aabb01d1dda48df0a0e38d"},{"path":".agents/rules/index.md","hash":"0b01f7dd1ba2f1504198da9f32acdaa0086fd7094b824cb4a7050260cd232d29"},{"path":".agents/rules/packages/config-ownership.md","hash":"88b4666cb758fb6f3588c3561965fc56fe5ed6aa86864d023435582ce7bbce6d"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/portless-local-urls.md","hash":"7116c77e0fd80bcbbe9df670f03bb51fe1c95302ae53f446c8a408e4661091e6"},{"path":".agents/rules/repository/shared-skill-source.md","hash":"1524fb91e39045b9417408a46cd1efa08aabf54fe49bcc887bc3fb0531f6f1eb"},{"path":".agents/skills/codebase-design/SKILL.md","hash":"a4b22a33f658d4cff395aed88eb6752dca8f929b57a2f129aba366236866a145"},{"path":".agents/skills/effect/SKILL.md","hash":"c0467cf7bcdb9284bb09af8cfab2475419ea46be26b42272c22549caf7e27d90"},{"path":".agents/skills/quality-types/SKILL.md","hash":"e85d2ae573b656a28ef83c1759c668a3cbd892ef8c17ff99bdf7b8149211cff5"},{"path":".agents/skills/simplify/SKILL.md","hash":"60671f89002e2dc6c1b30961d82915907119c82c39e49c78bee102e554fb40bf"},{"path":".agents/skills/tdd/SKILL.md","hash":"4f527b87a5a46aff7cd006aee5252c0dc3d7204bc3b11d0a24d6c0e82716cdf2"},{"path":".agents/skills/writing-for-agents/SKILL.md","hash":"a842323e664e5af104eac5c97ad22fda929ebeb62d81c501161ac1f6f482db58"},{"path":".devpunks/delivery/issue224/acceptance-audit.md","hash":"ce2c02de61c7cc9ddc0085fdc88d609c36cea425aaa3ffe164fd2b0158b746b5"},{"path":"AGENTS.md","hash":"cf17d46def3ed1e69e72bb804a755e311bfdd6774adfd00204eb6ad6144dfcd3"},{"path":"apps/cli/AGENTS.md","hash":"496e463f343080c274fef26718f00551dbf4873513aa308334b66295f9153057"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/AGENTS.md","hash":"6200edf9f9e7489ae1b6740c0e583ad8014e0faf9ff924faa0aa0c9e5a7c5692"},{"path":"apps/cli/src/data/AGENTS.md","hash":"d96e6710e332dd21042bd72da3323a17a40d15799143f70d83e7f824067e5ab2"},{"path":"apps/wiki/AGENTS.md","hash":"f3bfa16772dbaec2cab4960ae6a1240854930a5c93aa5fd7e2ea77abf5889db3"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/domains/issue-224-managed-lint-glossary.mdx","hash":"73d6a74cb8ad3010d6af3bdba4ca6969737f50775708b0715eace9ffa4276413"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/grilling/issue-224-managed-lint-grill-status.md","hash":"780dc56a0422530458c7e72ce5c2ee84ad2eb9ccae94f9aa2886799454a1365a"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md","hash":"cf3852172d36f2b9706ce997e803dce03659ce5753c5f0ffa0a2151b635c470f"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/PLAN.md","hash":"b1e4c5d36c4f91bd8585f7aad0d617a2db7f55ef83b6f428c783743e0bf52241"},{"path":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/SPEC.md","hash":"47901c0ee8d66c59f171ce8809d12a6617f0ede0863a53ac2875da51fed39414"},{"path":"docs/AGENTS.md","hash":"56ebac144eb2793bafc963f9ac8400b594dfa9854174e499f974ea70941bbf40"},{"path":"packages/config/AGENTS.md","hash":"9f57e76964f413e77a7a21328e15f96fc7322aaa582ccf91d5502084f26b136e"}],"source_set_hash":"d3cc01e86d6040081720c21d94a146b0e0eec7eb0c4fd038305d97625d4e1a6d","lens_outcomes":{"standards":"clean","skill_adherence":"clean","architecture":"clean","simplify":"clean","spec":"findings"},"findings":[{"id":"issue224-r8","lens":"spec","severity":"medium","location":"apps/cli/src/features/context-planning/managed-lint-ci-evidence.ts:9","impact":"Version-qualified direct Oxlint CI commands can remain active without a named adoption conflict, allowing CI to use a different policy/tool tuple.","evidence":"Parent read-only helper reproduction /tmp/issue224-versioned-ci-proof.json: npx oxlint emits a named CI conflict; npx oxlint@1.80.0, bunx oxlint@1.80.0 and pnpm dlx oxlint@1.80.0 all produce no conflict for the same workflow. This contradicts AC-027 and the existing package-script versioned-invocation contract.","action":"Recognize version-qualified Oxlint package invocations in the existing bounded CI command inventory, preserving commands and proving public generation conflicts without treating setup flags or quoted data as invocations.","return_route":"implementation"}],"routing":{"primary":"implementation","secondary_architecture_follow_up":false},"validation":[{"command":"Read frozen patch and governing sources; independently inspect each reviewer candidate and compare current bytes with file-hashes.json.","isolation":"proven-no-write","before_hash":"06a24e9666e4fdfc722182befd69ea46855ade1a56ca23f325fc452366bb4bbd","after_hash":"06a24e9666e4fdfc722182befd69ea46855ade1a56ca23f325fc452366bb4bbd","outcome":"passed","evidence":"Frozen84-path review snapshot; primary and independent challenger coverage complete. Parent adjudications preserve all candidate provenance. Implementation evidence includes340 lifecycle,109 adapters,5 package integrations, normal build/installed tarball, types/scoped lint and16 wiki tests; actual hooks retain456 unchanged wiki errors and unsupported pre-push --base. No validation writes to the reviewed target."}],"delivery_goal_identity":"issue-224-managed-lint","review_ordinal":1,"preceding_repair_ordinal":null,"review_epoch":{"protocol":"primary-challenger-v1","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","results":[{"reviewer_identity":"issue224-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"standards","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue224-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"skill_adherence","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","outcome":"findings","candidates":[{"location":"apps/wiki/content/docs/project/specs/cli/issue-224-managed-lint/IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md:97,113","evidence_pointer":"Frozen PLAN.md:257-259 and 724-725 require reading opensrc/effect.md and resolving the live Effect source before Effect behavior changes; the retained notes only assert that the source was resolved/inspected, and no frozen receipt identifies either required source-inspection action.","impact":"The implementation record cannot substantiate its claimed Effect-skill compliance for T1 and T6, leaving required skill evidence non-auditable.","proposed_severity":"low","proposed_return_route":"docs_ingest","uncertainty":"The inspection may have occurred, but the frozen packet contains no exact retained evidence for it."}],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue224-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"architecture","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue224-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"simplify","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue224-primary","role":"primary","coverage":"spec","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","outcome":"clean","candidates":[],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null},{"reviewer_identity":"issue224-challenger","role":"challenger","coverage":"Scope authorization and exclusion escapes; project policy composition and conflicting entrypoints; ownership-safe retirement and interruption recovery; bundled/installed runtime activation","packet_identity":"c29c87b39f4067f8001e58e291bee32866a31bfb747f89d6097aae10e58aaf34","outcome":"findings","candidates":[{"location":"apps/cli/src/features/context-planning/managed-lint-ci-evidence.ts:9,121","evidence_pointer":"The directOxlint matcher requires `oxlint` to be immediately followed by whitespace/punctuation/end, so it misses version-qualified CI invocations such as `npx oxlint@1.80.0 --config alternate.json .`; package-script inspection explicitly classifies that form as unresolved in apps/cli/src/features/managed-lint-policy/index.test.ts:201-224. SPEC.md OUT-015 and AC-027 require known conflicting CI commands to be retained and reported rather than allowing adoption to converge.","impact":"A version-qualified direct Oxlint CI entrypoint is left unchanged without a named conflict, while managed routes activate with a different explicit config/tool tuple. This reintroduces entrypoint-dependent policy behavior.","proposed_severity":"medium","proposed_return_route":"implementation","uncertainty":"Static review; no frozen regression covers a version-qualified CI command, but the regex boundary excludes it directly."}],"unavailable_coverage":[],"cause":null,"follow_up":null}],"adjudications":[{"candidate_refs":["[\"issue224-primary\",\"skill_adherence\",0]"],"finding_id":null,"evidence":"Rejected: IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES has the required T1/T6 Effect skill application records (source main resolved, existing Schema/error channels retained and types checked). The governing rules require reading the guide and resolving source, not an extra standalone receipt for each read-only command. Existing T6 transcripts independently corroborate both actions: /tmp/issue224-t6-stage1-worker.jsonl:34,38 and /tmp/issue224-t6-health-worker.jsonl:54,68; parent retained exact command readback in /tmp/issue224-effect-source-inspection-proof.json. No missing implementation obligation or contradicted behavior was established."},{"candidate_refs":["[\"issue224-challenger\",\"Scope authorization and exclusion escapes; project policy composition and conflicting entrypoints; ownership-safe retirement and interruption recovery; bundled/installed runtime activation\",0]"],"finding_id":"issue224-r8","evidence":"Parent read-only helper reproduction /tmp/issue224-versioned-ci-proof.json: npx oxlint emits a named CI conflict; npx oxlint@1.80.0, bunx oxlint@1.80.0 and pnpm dlx oxlint@1.80.0 all produce no conflict for the same workflow. This contradicts AC-027 and the existing package-script versioned-invocation contract."}]}}