Lefthook Commit Gate Delivery Phase Handoff

Phase: closeout Status: in_progress Scope: IP-425 through provider Task IP-426 on feat/pre-commit-hooks. Artifacts: SPEC.md, PLAN.md, IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md, retained review report. Validation: focused behavior, API/backoffice package suites, CLI lint/typecheck/focused release tests, repository check, isolated consumer validator/runtime, and exact affected 23-task lint/check graph pass; the full CLI suite exceeds the local command runner's ten-minute ceiling without an assertion failure. Review/debug/docs state: clean retained implementation review plus clean supplemental CI-repair review; docs ingest complete. UI Evidence: not applicable; no UI surface changed. Next suggested route: push the exact validated head, require hosted CI green, then complete and read back IP-426 before IP-425. Blockers: hosted exact-head CI and subsequent Devpunks Linear completion readback remain.

delivery_goal_identity: IP-425/IP-426:lefthook-commit-gate accepted_bounds_identity: SPEC.md+PLAN.md:IP-425/IP-426 accepted_bounds_hash: 57c435fef13faea16c18dc988ab7af61b90309fec6215ee35e8c3045792b32e8 review_lineage_id: 028feb729b62632137fdb156c2983df00bd4e7fe91a6a37ab9d16170eb2db09c review_run_id: 8132ee8ba3a903ad6c4f7949a590ec87e83632884f268ab4a1f3c8e05f317f1c state: closeout primary_route: closeout secondary_architecture_follow_up: none post_debt_route: none review_count: 1 repair_count: 1 authoritative_report_path: apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-028feb729b62632137fd-20260901T175731Z-0ecbcf5ca136-review-report.md authoritative_report_commit: 02a98e9ede00d1417458cdaf116e13236c25d309 verified_retained_ref: pending retention push stable_finding_ids: [] debt_follow_up_artifact: none debt_follow_up_keys: [] captured_debt_finding_ids: []

Review Phase Runtime Handoffs

review-handoff-v1
Phase: closeout
Status: complete
Scope: mode: delivery; IP-425/IP-426 Commit Gate changed paths
Artifacts: accepted_bounds_identity: SPEC.md+PLAN.md:IP-425/IP-426; accepted_bounds_hash: 57c435fef13faea16c18dc988ab7af61b90309fec6215ee35e8c3045792b32e8; normalized_target_locator: feat/pre-commit-hooks@9a633d2395aef00f77eaf442506498bd21cf8d8b+dirty; frozen_target_evidence_locator: review report Identity section; frozen_source_evidence_locator: review report governing hashes; snapshot_hash: 0ecbcf5ca136c2b8fcebdafb6eb8d950bfd7642701c31edaa6b228f6a2c6590b; source_set_hash: review report governing hashes; local_report_path: apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-028feb729b62632137fd-20260901T175731Z-0ecbcf5ca136-review-report.md; local_report_sha256: bff8053653bb148ece252c4dd82c5ca93ff966d6052e86a38646a3ea5e1f9b13; report_commit: 02a98e9ede00d1417458cdaf116e13236c25d309; retained_ref: pending retention push; stable_finding_ids: []; primary_route: docs_ingest; secondary_architecture_follow_up: none
Counters: review_count: 1; repair_count: 1; recovered_review_count: 1; ordinal: 1
Routing: current_route: closeout; post_debt_route: none; debt_follow_up_artifact: none; debt_follow_up_keys: []; captured_debt_finding_ids: []
Exit: docs ingest complete; next suggested route: closeout; blocker: provider/full-suite evidence remains bounded
Attempt: 1

Handback

• Initial goal and accepted bounds: deliver IP-425/IP-426 Commit Gate on feat/pre-commit-hooks from immutable base b0c53c2552e3c0a1ab34519e7486a9bfe11d1fbb, preserving provider and settings authority.
• Last known-good state: implementation and docs committed at 02a98e9ede00d1417458cdaf116e13236c25d309; clean retained review; review handoff commit a6f32b68a62b926e890d31bd23e8b3ee7267758f; PR #184 open; release classification none.
• Attempts and evidence: pushed the recorded branch and opened PR #184 against main; GitHub returned mergeStateStatus: DIRTY. Fresh git merge-tree found conflicts in .devpunks/settings.json, .devpunks/scaffold-manifest.json, wiki navigation, wiki log, runbook projections, and docs/README.md.
• Blocker: the settings conflict changes asset-provider and backlog-project authority, so a merge or rebase cannot be resolved mechanically without an explicit policy choice.
• Proposed next action: merge current origin/main, union mechanical navigation, log, and docs conflicts, use the human-selected .devpunks/settings.json authority, rebuild generated receipts, rerun focused and outward validation plus release classification, push PR #184, and read CI.
• Why authority is required: selecting current main or preserving the branch changes provider/project configuration beyond the accepted Commit Gate implementation.
• Exact human decision required: authorize either current main settings (assetProviderSlug: github, current Linear project URL) or branch settings (assetProviderSlug: linear, initiative URL) for conflict resolution.

Authority resolution

The guard passed from repository and user authority without inventing a policy: the accepted hierarchy names the Linear Initiative as the backlog root, while current operator docs explicitly reject legacy Linear /project/ destinations and require a top-level Root Initiative. The merge therefore preserved the branch linear asset provider and Initiative URL, unioned mechanical wiki/docs conflicts, and retained all current main release-recovery work. Focused tests, typechecks, build, repository checks, wiki synchronization, and diff checks passed on the merged tree.