Managed Lint Implementation Notes

Authority and delivery state

The user approved all Q1–Q24 decisions and authorized full delivery. SPEC.md remains the accepted authority. Work stays on team/stefan/issue-224-lint-boundaries. PR 225 was opened above PR 223; merging the parent and deleting its branch automatically closed the draft. The original parent and origin/main had identical trees. PR225 was reopened and retargeted to main. The already-merged parent ref was restored only to recover GitHub PR state, then removed after exact readback. The child was rebased onto main at 71e84184be2e0eff48cffae43face01df5d300ab; the first implementation publication reached 7055f06c8a97dca2103b4563c31d8d7fc5bc84bb. Root returned PR225 to draft after required CI failed. No merge, product release, or consumer remote mutation is authorized.

The execution graph uses planning-only identities. GitHub issue 224 remains the source issue; no provider Task mutation or lifecycle readback is claimed. The existing commit/push hook failures remain recorded in parent state. The concrete repair is now locally validated. The initial publication exception is consumed; on 2026-09-23 the user authorized exactly one additional hook-bypassed commit and one push for this frozen repair. Publication and provider readback remain pending.

Current CI repair status — 2026-09-23

After the first publication, required CI reported 58/893 source-suite failures across 10 files (/tmp/issue224-ci-source-clean.log). The first built observations included two Project Verifier failures; the complete built RED was four failures and 66 passes (/tmp/issue224-ci-built.log). Final frozen local proof now closes local T7/final A4 acceptance. Delivery/provider closeout remains pending: PR225 still publishes 7055f06c8a97dca2103b4563c31d8d7fc5bc84bb as a draft after those original failures. No fourth commit or second push has occurred, and no green remote checks are claimed. Earlier narrow tests, installed-package observations and real-consumer proofs below remain historical evidence for their exact inputs.

The plan's current frontier records the five completed/frozen test owners and the separately scoped helper/catalog follow-ups. Legacy fixtures now provide the accepted saved scope authority and assert the shared runner and wiki exclusion behavior while preserving safety/ownership assertions. No accepted Q1–Q24 decision, AC, requirement or architecture changed. Root accepted the cumulative local evidence below after all source/runtime inputs froze; publication remains a separate delivery gate.

The pre-catalog built/update rows retain their historical observations; the final runs below supersede them for local acceptance. Release61 is reused only because its release inputs are unchanged. Earlier review notes that left full source/update/package/static proof pending are now superseded by the corresponding final results; their provider limitation remains.

All three initially authorized commits and the first authorized push have been consumed. On 2026-09-23 the user explicitly authorized exactly one additional hook-bypassed commit and one push for this frozen repair. No broader gate exception or further publication authority is granted.

Final cumulative local gates and identity

Final CLI SHA256 is a8ff8cd55397b707a3423b1df1b2a0226e35a8289401937385655be0d47fea4d; the validated installed archive SHA256 is d4f6d19133bbaf8c593a37ec752825599265a47f8e62bc63e3165c47b34ba13e. These identities supersede the earlier package/CLI hashes for current acceptance without erasing those prior observations.

Parent focused reviews /tmp/issue224-ci-test-review.md and /tmp/issue224-ci-runtime-review.md report no findings in their respective frozen scopes. The test review's helper/policy/catalog exclusions are covered by the runtime review. The original retained full-review ordinal remains1 and repair_count remains1; these focused reviews do not create another full-review ordinal. Local T7/final A4 are accepted with the retained T8 proof and empty migration ledger. Delivery/provider closeout remains pending.

Final consumer revalidation

Both reports live under the existing .devpunks/delivery/issue224/consumer-repos/ evidence directories and record the final CLI SHA256 above.

Final scoped docs validation

bun run --cwd apps/wiki check:content passes with current content. bun run --cwd apps/wiki test:ci passes16/16 tests across4 files: public routes6, public wiki contract3, sync-content6 and source-page-tree1. Logs are /tmp/issue224-ci-docs-final-content.log and /tmp/issue224-ci-docs-final-contracts.log. Both owned Markdown files pass git diff --check; all8 task JSON records parse and all3 relative links resolve. T1–T6/T8 task records, accepted ACs and historical review/architecture evidence remain unchanged; T7 changes only status/log. A readonly identity check confirms1,328/1,328 source hashes unchanged and the final built CLI hash above. These document checks do not establish remote CI status.

Helper repair and superseded attempts

T7-ci-helper owns only apps/cli/test-fixtures/portfolio/application.ts. The initial readRepoSettings forwarding attempt passed static checks but stripped lint from saved settings and left 7/8 plan-only tests failing; that attempt and its hashes are superseded. The frozen helper uses the canonical ProjectSettings service read, retains normalized lint settings, and treats only missing settings as absent. Runtime witnesses preserve explicit empty selection, reject invalid scopes and leave saved bytes unchanged.

The cached fixture copy also converted relative symlinks into absolute links to deleted original fixtures. Both seed and restore copies now use verbatimSymlinks: true, preserving cache reuse and receipt bytes. The retained ordered public pair went from one pass/one failure to two passes without test assertion changes (/tmp/issue224-ci-policy-seed-focus.log, /tmp/issue224-helper-cache-pair-green.log). The policy owner's later full 50-case result supersedes the helper handoff's earlier full-suite-pending note. Frozen helper SHA256: 0335a933cbf681337da8f667deb9d4e3fe512bca6f5f9a99b7955ebcd9ce1155; complete history and static/runtime evidence: /tmp/issue224-ci-policy-helper-handoff.md.

Catalog production regression and bounded repair

Selected-owner-only planning retired the managed root workspaces.catalog.oxlint leaf while an unselected package still declared oxlint: "catalog:". The separate runtime source worker owns only apps/cli/src/scaffold/output.ts and new apps/cli/src/scaffold/managed-lint-catalog-retirement.test.ts. The repair retains an unchanged exact receipt-owned catalog value while effective future references remain, independently of lint enrollment, including when all lint owners are deselected. Planned manifest/dependency overlays and exact dependency receipts distinguish surviving authored references from managed dependencies due to retire.

An unselected consumer retains its exact existing catalog version, including 1.78.0 or 1.71.0; unrelated selected literal requirements do not upgrade it. Authored or edited catalog values are not adopted. Removing the last effective consumer permits safe retirement. Existing selected-consumer catalog compatibility planning remains unchanged. The temporary upgrade refinement was rejected/reverted; it and stale version-failure observations remain superseded history, not accepted behavior or final evidence.

Public RED recorded a missing catalog value after real update/reconciliation (/tmp/issue224-ci-catalog-red.log). The final accepted-semantics run passes 11 new public cases plus two current root-dependency cases: all four dependency sections, last-consumer removal, generated dependency/catalog retirement, full deselection, future selected references, modified-dependency conflicts and authored/edited catalog boundaries. The readonly unselected policy witness also passes (/tmp/issue224-ci-policy-unselected-final.log). Frozen SHA256 values from the handoff are fab2aa0e7159bb1341f00093347074bb6ebfe33dbd4801617364f37b978e2a20 for output.ts and 8bfe418828772aec5093d94ca145a720f538e50acdfbc3b14f35dc43492859c3 for the new test. The public fixture models the external dependency installer; the separate final build, installed-package, cumulative lanes and real-consumer results above supply the broader proof.

This current status supersedes earlier local-pending states and historical completion/publication statements below, preserving their evidence and exact-input limits. Local acceptance and publication authorization do not establish remote check success or publication completion. The accepted AC wording and original full-review ordinal remain unchanged.

Validation before implementation

Relevant runtime evidence

Oxlint 1.80.0 supports explicit --config and --disable-nested-config, but neither --stdin-filename nor --stdin-filepath. A policy overriding src/a.test.ts produces no diagnostics on that exact path and a no-debugger error on both a renamed sibling and a child temporary copy. Temporary filename normalization alone cannot prove edit-hook policy parity. The hook task must prove original logical-path semantics while preserving its controlled publication lifecycle. Disposable evidence: /tmp/hi224-stdin-probe-h29_xq15.

Remaining work

Local T7/final A4 proof is complete. Delivery/provider closeout now awaits the authorized commit and push, exact provider readback, and remote checks. PR225 remains draft at the first published head; no fourth commit, second push, or remote GREEN is claimed yet. The original full-review ordinal1 and repair_count1 remain unchanged.

Manual Review Checklist

UI Evidence Links

Not applicable: this delivery changes CLI and generated runtime behavior, with no browser UI changes.

Local tool preparation

The inherited CLI lint config uses Effect's Oxlint plugin. The frozen install intentionally skipped lifecycle scripts, so an initial narrow lint attempt reported Unknown plugin: effecttsgo. Running the repository's existing bun run prepare successfully patched the installed Oxlint and tsgolint binaries and Oxlint declarations. This changed local dependencies only; /tmp/issue224-prepare.log records the result. Later lint proof must use this prepared toolchain.

Current execution gates

T1–T6/T8 rows retain their earlier owning evidence; current cumulative local acceptance is supplied by the final frozen gates above. Local T7/final A4 are closed while delivery/provider publication remains pending. Historically, the first review epoch was invalidated before completion for an unused import found by the root gate; cleanup passed root check and43 hook tests. Its then-zero review count is superseded by the retained original full review at ordinal1; repair_count remains1.

This map identifies ownership and shared seams. Historical generated-runtime and adoption proofs retain their recorded input limits; current repaired-source proof is accepted through the final local gates above. Read-only health does not execute lint or establish source cleanliness.

The following skill, architecture, AC and repair entries retain historical evidence in execution order. The current CI status and gate table above supersede their completion claims; they do not change accepted requirements or erase prior observations.

Parent reconciliation corrected the PLAN's stale hard wiki/build shorthand to hard wiki plus saved exclusions. This records the already accepted and implemented boundary from T2/T5; it adds no universal build exclusion or product decision.

Skill Application Evidence

Applicable rule evidence

T1: HI-CLI-001 and HI-CLI-003 pass (local settings and command composition stay CLI-owned). HI-REPO-001 is not applicable: no remote or shared API contract changed. Spec/grill artifacts passed HI-WIKI-001/003 content and 16 contract tests. Final docs, managed asset, and release evaluations remain pending their owning changes.

Historical architecture conformance evidence

Initial behavior proof supports RAC-1/RAC-2; A1 remains reopened for current lint and freshness repair: settings owns saved intent; the portable module owns eligibility, exact owner selection, and explicit config/local-tool command construction. The resolver does not execute processes or publish files. Settings and runtime are independent implementations of their distinct boundaries; runtime checks the derived settings identity.

settings intent -> derived route contract -> portable resolver
                                      (process adapters pending)

The frozen declaration hash is 8e4cf99f081e55d5e61ede891de7dc17a6b76d905f4a43026a8d7d7d056915a1; implementation hash 420a9db0967de1c99876794b8988897daf837cbb030c8c22e4e809a3b7799206. T2 guidance application: TDD (six observed failure categories repaired), codebase-design (one portable seam), quality-types (validated unknown boundary data plus declarations). Existing migration entries remain open until adoption completes; no live convergence claim.

Historical parent integration findings

The earlier T2 narrow lint proof did not cover the inherited app configuration. Exact invocation from apps/cli found 303 errors, mostly missing JS type information, plus 17 warnings in managed-lint.mjs. T2 gate and A1 lint conformance are reopened for scoped JSDoc/narrowing repair; no rule suppressions or weaker configuration are authorized. The runtime behavior tests remain valid evidence of their tested behavior. Repair waits for T5 to release its read dependency, then affected tests must rerun. A briefly launched ephemeral repair worker was cancelled before edits; all three T2 hashes remained unchanged.

T3 initial eight tests, actual Oxlint diagnostic parity, and parent exact scoped lint pass (25 advisory warnings). Parent identified integration gaps: unrelated typecheck scripts must not be mistaken for lint conflicts; safe run-script aliases need relation analysis; second updates need exact receipt-owned generated command evidence. A scoped worker owns this repair.

Historical integration and repair evidence

Plan reviewer approved the freshness/declaration/generation-input scope amendments. Release T4 only after T2 identity validation, T3 compatible identities and T5 adapter tests on the repaired resolver bytes pass.

Exact inherited configuration comparison on a detached HEAD worktree found 139 pre-existing errors in commit-gate-runner.mjs, zero in the unchanged test files. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-baseline-runtime-lint.json; disposable worktree removed. New/changed runtime code requires no new errors. Investigation found packaged .mjs files absent from the CLI TypeScript project; T5 owns a bounded tsconfig correction to supply real Node types, preserving strict checks. This is not permission to suppress rules or use a weaker config.

T2 now owns resolver freshness/type repair. T5 released T2 read custody and owns only its adapter annotations/declaration plus local type-project correction. After those settle, rerun all affected runtime tests and type/lint checks before release. T3 integration repair has passing focused tests/lint/types; exact receipt command identity alone does not encode prior warning threshold, so generation must preserve threshold evidence from the verified route.

T3 Task Gate passed after integration repair: 16 public tests (original eight preserved), exact inherited-config lint exit 0, CLI typecheck exit 0. RED alias and receipt tests each produced the intended conflict before repair. Final source hashes: index.ts 5162fb241d1280a4c88c65fa9f2e04a89b11606aba3f4b86d18f220f00faaff4; index.test.ts 4348c3367ebc15ce2f8e6d81c165b18ce2ae68d747c2990ed6236d58015bd70e. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t3-integration-result.md and retained JSONL command stream. T3 custody released. TDD, codebase-design, quality-types applied; HI-CLI-001/003 pass.

T2 repaired Task Gate passed: 9 public tests including resolve-time and command-time policy freshness, exact inherited Oxlint zero errors, strict typecheck. policyInputs is optional only for no-policy routes. Implementation/declaration/tests hashes are respectively b379451829b21e871dcbf73aa6bf477888aa35ef69e390359cb8c8b97eda2617, eecf9fd3adf642d0d826239239f127720bce095f0ada1176e678437f57fb4530, 63fe8670fb5f1d7cd49669949ff7127eaa38db49b43779de5c45690e53ce9b03; shared type-project hash 30fcd932ec0ea6ff6b0b3c03500d0caa8f8dd7a6ef991a98e8cd31dfd86c7fc4. A1 restored after current lint/freshness proof; adapter/materialization responsibilities remain downstream.

T5 parent aggregate concern refined by public RED: repository command did execute, but received empty HI_STAGED_FILES when only selected child files changed. Both selected-root and unselected-root cases now receive eligible child paths; per-kind owner formatter excludes wiki/fixtures. Final adapter validation pending.

T5 Task Gate passed for changed behavior: 48 adapter tests, real Oxlint config/tool/typed/mirror proof, CLI typecheck and diff check, no new hard lint errors. One inherited strict-void-return finding remains at unchanged promisify(execFileCallback); broad typed project correction reduced inherited gate findings from 139 to one without suppressions. This is reported inherited debt, not a claim of a clean full repository lint. Evidence /tmp/t5-root-repair-{tests.log,types.log,lint.json,inputs.sha256}. T2/T3 combined parent suite: 25 passing tests, /tmp/issue224-seam-tests.log. Current resolver/declaration hashes remain frozen. T4 now consumes these proven seams.

Additional parent runtime probe reopened empty-source handling in T5: Oxlint 1.80 returns exit1 plus an expected no-files prefix and valid empty JSON when all inputs are ignored/non-JS. The runner currently treats the prefixed output as malformed operational failure. Evidence /tmp/issue224-no-source-probe.json; disposable fixture removed. Repair waits T4 runtime read custody, then invalidated materialization checks rerun. Other resolver/policy/adapter proofs remain valid for their tested input sets.

GitHub stack lifecycle changed during delivery: #223 merged into main at 2026-09-22T14:24:57Z (71e84184be2e0eff48cffae43face01df5d300ab). Its source branch was deleted; #225 timeline records base_ref_deleted at 14:25:02Z immediately followed by automatic closure. The implementation remains authorized. Closeout should retarget/reopen #225 onto main containing the merged parent rather than recreate a deleted base. The child itself was not merged. No working-tree rebase occurs while scoped writers are active.

Current A2 graph (presentation via show-me; not completion proof):

saved software scopes + preserved project policy
  -> generation (T4 active)
      -> derived route -> shared runtime
                         -> package/root/CI commands
                         -> gate/edit adapters (empty-source repair pending)
                         -> candidate/update/check (T6 next)

Ownership remains local to CLI composition and packaged runtime assets. General guidance discovery is not redefined by saved lint ownership. A2 cannot close until generated materialization and repaired empty-source runtime proof pass.

T4 W3 progress retained at /tmp/hi-t4-evidence: first public RED reproduced unwanted unselected/wiki/fixture configs; wiki producer RED/GREEN removed lint/format artifacts and scripts; generated real Oxlint preserved custom warning limit7 and ordinary tests. Targeted suite reached98/99. The remaining second-generation failure revealed full T3 inventory hashes mixed with active compiled policy identities. T4 requested a bounded producer repair. Parent ended its ephemeral process after current tools completed, retained all files and evidence, and released producer read custody. Disjoint T3 (active policyInputs contract) and T5 (expected empty-source output) repairs now run. T4 resume brief includes remaining parent activation/custom-root checks and mandates rematerialization after producer changes.

Parent public probes retained two further boundaries for final repair: /tmp/issue224-prereq-probe.log shows an existing oxfmt-enabled repository still proposes the edit hook with missing scopes, partial owner config with another owner conflicted, and an unselected root custom broad lint command reported ready without conflict. These are planning facts; direct live activation must be proved/gated by T4 and candidate activation by T6. /tmp/issue224-python-scope-probe.json confirms the hook blocks pyproject-only Python work on missing JS selection before reaching its existing Ruff path. Preserving Python behavior is required by accepted non-goals/OUT014; repair remains within T5, with shared exclusion semantics as needed. Disposable probe repositories removed.

T3 active-policy repair passed its Task Gate:18 public tests (two new REDs then GREEN), actual Oxlint policy parity retained, inherited lint zero errors31 advisory warnings, CLI types. Ready result policyInputs contains sorted hashes for selected chain/transitive policies/local plugins; inputs retains all inventory/comparison reads and conflicts stay enforced. Witness /tmp/hi224-t3-policy-inputs-witness.json proves base+project active identities. Current implementation/test hashes e5f75381d02177a347aab4f72f64d7b8ab3e4ec4d81f80f6e4a615844be5edd5 and 364a67bfbec811ab7306d82f0a15551c6a90173bd9cffa2e8c5715cddd2f5a7c. T4 must now consume that field rather than filtering broad inputs.

T5 empty-source repair passed:73 resolver/adapter tests, CLI types, formatting, inherited lint on changed runner/tests; broader lint only recorded unchanged promisify debt. Public actual Oxlint empty response now returns clean/0, while malformed/error output and formatter coverage stay enforced. Evidence /tmp/t5-empty-repair-handoff.md, /tmp/t5-empty-runtime-final.json; runtime hash 583c462bde72f9eb882abab63e984634272af71e18e285956ec676fbe3835fc9, test hash 76e3f8ab62406f5b3b5509dbe63364526b0f82e922db49c26c26b5c80b5b1f8f, unchanged declaration hash dc92cf56e7f56c521039e35b8004af538c64f742f59c3988c3ada14388fef74b. T5 remains reopened only for independent Python preservation. T4 producer proofs must rematerialize after all repairs.

Read-only plan review approved the bounded preservation sequence: T5 runner custody released -> T2 common exclusion predicate/declaration with public proof -> parent gate -> existing T5 Python hook repair -> parent gate -> T4 rematerialization. /tmp/issue224-exclusion-plan-review-result.md. The seam keeps exclusions shared without inventing JS ownership for Python; approved Non-Goals/OUT014/020 remain unchanged.

Actual hook preview still classified an ignored JS source as malformed JSON after the runner empty-work repair because it re-parses raw stdout; mirror fix/verify also have separate result classification. Evidence /tmp/issue224-hook-empty-probe.json. T5 hook preservation repair now includes sharing canonical runner process classification/execution within its existing runtime ownership. T2 routing remains independent; provider path normalization/rendering remain hook-owned. This is an entrypoint parity repair, with public hook preview/fix RED/GREEN required.

T2 common-exclusion API passed its parent gate:13 tests including original9, separate export/invalid-path REDs, inherited lint zero errors40 advisory warnings, CLI types/format. isManagedQualityPathExcluded({path,exclude}) is the same predicate used by all resolver call sites; invalid nonnormalized paths throw TypeError and caller validates exclusion strings. Current source/declaration/test hashes: 99cb67ccca8ffe7515b0be789b67b66e8f41feb136c2486b13790ad05e25cb31, 0e70ec565d882e6fadbb1d6de2b47e649675231f9ad1a291ecda199bcefaf694, b86d4bf0dd980f10fa4fb984bf1c8e0e7d2e8951f02b3efd13e5554ed61fdf57. A1 restored. T5 now consumes frozen T2/T3 contracts for Python preservation and shared result classification.

T5 adapter repair reached 101 passing combined tests with two failures caused by an unsupported universal build exclusion assumed in the worker brief. Parent corrected the brief against accepted hard wiki roots and explicit project exclusions; frozen T2 semantics remain unchanged. The ephemeral writer was stopped after completed commands and its files retained. Custody transferred to native /root/t5_adapters for bounded final gate; no overlapping writer remains.

T5 final adapter gate passed:104 public tests, CLI types, exact inherited lint zero hard errors; parent verified all hashes in /tmp/t5-python-final-inputs.sha256. Actual uv + Ruff0.15.7 pyproject-only proof in /tmp/t5-real-ruff-proof.json confirms read-only preview/F821 and controlled formatting without JS scopes; disposable project removed. Hook consumes canonical executeManagedLintCommand result classification. Explicit project build exclusion corrects unsupported brief shorthand without widening frozen T2 rules. T4 resumes against these frozen runtime inputs; final generation/materialization proof must use current bytes.

T4 preservation decision: Q10/OUT010 makes oxlint.project.json the new-policy naming convention, not a requirement to copy every legacy authored input. Existing compatible JSON/JSONC remains project-owned at its original path, included in canonical policy and exact fingerprints. Removing the draft managed copy avoids wrongful retirement without adding ownership schema. AC013 still requires one managed explicit execution target and disabled nested discovery. T4 proves repeat generation/deselection preserves original input; unresolved command authority remains a conflict.

T4 parent verification:106 tests, CLI types, six-file inherited lint and format passed; all /tmp/t4-final-inputs.sha256 hashes verified. Active compiler policyInputs, authored policy ownership, second generation, direct activation blocking, gate canonical routes and pnpm negations are proved. OUT015 known CI invocation inventory remains unresolved in worker handoff, so T4 gate stays open for that bounded public conflict/parity repair before T6. No final A2 claim yet.

A2 cumulative checkpoint passed: T3 effective policy compiler; T4 saved-owner/local-framework generation and exact canonical contract; T5 shared runtime classification and safety. 107 generation tests and104 adapter tests, actual supported Oxlint and Ruff public proof, types/scoped lint, parent-verified frozen hashes. Known direct CI Oxlint paths produce named conflicts; managed CI script delegation remains eligible. Shared ownership graph matches planned module boundaries; no new project-policy ownership variant introduced. M1/M2 remain until T6 coherent adoption/health removes legacy live routing. CI inventory membership must enter generation freshness, including added workflows.

T6 internal wave begins after A2: adoption owns runtime/update/scaffold-update; health owns readonly repository-check and source/CI generation freshness. Readonly plan review found broad old handoff and coupled application.test.ts import; parent corrected scope headers and deferred coupled suites/types until both freeze. Observer API/result union stays stable. Sessions80937/59718 own disjoint scopes; one cumulative Task Gate remains. Bounded ephemeral scoped workers retain the same ownership/skill contracts and do not nest delegation.

T6 intermediate evidence (not final gate): generation freshness public suite56 passed after source-byte and CI inventory REDs; affected-owner planner12 passed including rootless settings and shared policy fanout. Missing-selection preview and readonly-health RED/GREEN repaired. Full candidate/publication, exact health context and coupled validation remain active; evidence /tmp/t6-health-freshness-green.log, /tmp/issue224-t6-adoption-plan-green.log, /tmp/issue224-t6-adoption-runtime-green.log, /tmp/t6-health-selection-green.log. T7 read-only preflight confirmed common npm exec CI matcher gap; parent retains this bounded T4 repair before final acceptance after T6 releases generation read custody.

T6 health/freshness custody released:75 independent tests (61 observer,14 public health), format and identical56-input hashes passed. Parent verified /tmp/t6-health-final-inputs.sha256 and reviewed frozen health/adapter diff. Typed shared resolver remains authority; generated evidence is schema-decoded; local command inspection does not execute lint, and persisted artifact reads use confined regular-file APIs. Detailed handoff recovered at /tmp/t6-health-handoff.md because final result output overwrote its initially detailed file. Coupled application tests, CLI types and type-aware lint remain pending adoption freeze; no final T6/A3 claim.

T6 candidate integration found and repaired pruning of project-policy inputs stored in an unselected nested project: exclusion from software execution does not exclude a declared shared policy dependency from candidate closure. Worker reports actual installed Oxlint rootless preview and unchanged authored policy bytes; final scope gate still pending. Older preview fixtures are being authored with explicit authority; removed agent-output fallback and incomplete executable-config cache assumptions must map to new shared-classifier/validate-fresh coverage in final audit.

T7 authoring preparation

Parent split T7 into isolated two-file authoring and final runtime/package proof. Readonly plan review required no test execution while T6 transitive inputs remain mutable; this restriction is in the worker brief. Final T7 still waits the T6 gate, T4 integration repairs, and T8 sync for packaging. No production scope or acceptance outcome changed.

Shared classifier regression identified by adoption

The candidate suite retains three operational-stderr assertions. They expose a shared T5 classifier defect: the benign warning allowlist is applied only to empty-work reports, so ordinary JSON plus configuration stderr can be classified as findings or clean. T5 gate reopens for one shared repair after T6 releases read custody. Preview-specific parsing or weaker tests would violate entrypoint parity. Prior successful T5 tests remain historical evidence; affected proof must rerun.

Focused integration follow-through

T5 shared stderr/native-result repair passed 103 adapter tests, inherited lint and format; parent verified /tmp/t5-stderr-final-inputs.sha256. T6 caller projection restores bounded redacted native status/signal/cause and the shared failure category; CLI types pass. The stage1 suite reached 142 tests, but parent rejected changing the pre-existing null-status category from process to config-load. A tiny shared-runtime repair will preserve that compatibility and restore the assertion. This is not final acceptance.

The remaining 64 inherited lint errors belong to health/freshness (mostly new test JSON typing and assertion grouping). A disjoint worker owns only those paths; no suppressions or weaker rules are authorized. Parent temporarily transfers the single runtime null-status regression to the shared-runtime repair worker after T6 source freeze. T4 generation waits the repaired runtime; health runtime tests wait T4 because their fixture imports generation. Combined types and lifecycle proof run after every relevant writer freezes.

Final producer integration and lifecycle gate

Parent verified current T4 owned/producer, T5 null-process and T6 health-lint SHA256 receipts after every writer exited. T4 final suite passes 149 tests plus scoped lint/format, proving actual root aggregation, child package lint, staged gate execution, ordinary-test inclusion, wiki/fixture exclusion, npm exec conflict reporting and repeated legacy threshold preservation. T5 passes 103 adapter tests with unexpected-stderr rejection and native process-failure facts preserved. Historical failed producer snapshots above are superseded by these frozen reports.

T6 stage2 is released to native t6_final; it owns only PLAN T6 paths. Full repeat materialization remains unproved: T4’s low-level experiment rejected a projection receipt, while its repeat-generation proof applied planned lint artifacts only. T6 must establish the supported public lifecycle and diagnose that boundary before A3 acceptance. T7 runtime proof and T8 publication/sync remain dependent gates. Global/project agent settings and the selected apps-cli specialist manifest were reverified; no configuration changed.

T6 first coupled gate: 284 passed/46 failed (45 update fixture assumptions and one owner-local generated-config fixture), with whole CLI types and scoped lint exit 0. Minimal fixture migration declares saved intent; missing-selection/disabled semantics stay explicit tests. Focused missing-receipt recovery and repeat update now pass. A separate public handoff-only repeat fails projection because the desired edited-file hook is absent (/tmp/issue224-t6-projection-debug.json and focused RED). T4 performs readonly emitter diagnosis while T6 finishes bounded fixture repairs; no broad rerun or final lifecycle claim until the mismatch is resolved.

The repeat-update trigger is now isolated: T3 inventories the --oxlint option in effect-tsgo patch --no-typescript --oxlint as a lint executable and reports a false conflict. The setup command must be preserved. T4 separately filters unavailable hook source emission while retaining that hook in persisted/projected context, causing adapters to reference a missing canonical file. T6 is frozen with only two fixture edits; parent verified its receipt, candidate tests pass 39/39, and temporary instrumentation was removed byte-exactly. T3 owns command-invocation evidence repair, followed by T4 coherent effective hook context and then the resumed T6 lifecycle gate. No lint readiness or routes will be fabricated to pass projection.

T3 command repair gate passed: public policy suite20 tests, inherited scoped lint (zero errors) and format; /tmp/issue224-t3-command-handoff.md, parent-verified frozen receipt. Bounded executable-token inventory excludes setup --oxlint while retaining direct/path/compound/versioned/wrapped invocations and existing conservative lint/check aliases. The whole CLI type check identified an extraneous version field in the newly migrated T6 candidate fixture, retained for its owning worker. T4 projection repair is active under its original ownership; no target topology or public seam changes.

T4 projection gate passed:151 tests, inherited scoped lint and format. Public opaque-conflict materialization now persists/projects the same effective hook context used by canonical file emission; missing/conflict stays unresolved and Python applicability is retained. Parent verified /tmp/issue224-t4-projection-frozen.sha256; detailed /tmp/issue224-t4-projection-handoff.md. The handoff-only update fixture clears projection and reaches a separate preview-count assertion, now owned by resumed T6. T3/T4 production inputs are frozen for the final coupled lifecycle gate; no public seam/topology changes or suppressions were introduced.

T6 stage3 coupled gate completed:310/330 tests pass across nine files; all20 remaining failures are in update/run.test.ts. Runtime123, candidate39, repository health/application, freshness, planner/cache and presenter suites pass. Current CLI types pass after correcting the fixture settings shape. Remaining update failures are being grouped into explicit-selection fixture assumptions and recovery/convergence behavior; final A3 is still pending. /tmp/issue224-t6-stage3-tests.log retains this completed run. No overlapping broad rerun is active.

Stage3 focused diagnosis confirms a supported interruption/retry defect: after successful candidate writes but failed receipt persistence, T6 verifies pending structured authority into its local manifest view; generation independently rereads the old live receipt and treats the applied lint command/config as unowned. Evidence /tmp/issue224-t6-stage3-recovery-blocker.md; strict recovery assertion remains unchanged. T4 is examining the ownership seam readonly while T6 corrects explicit fixture selection/topology. Recovery must accept only exact verified pending work and retain modified/unowned protection and read-only planning/check.

T6 focused fixture reconciliation preserves existing assertions: pnpm explicit scopes, converged handoff-only topology, and wiki settings intent pass3 cases; unchanged no-lint managed/generation/unclosed/caller readiness guards and missing/old catalog repair pass6 more. Evidence /tmp/issue224-t6-stage3-fixtures.log and /tmp/issue224-t6-stage3-fixture-validation.log. Remaining pending-publication recovery requires independently recorded expected file/selection hashes and a shared effective ownership input; no filename/current-byte authority will be inferred.

The pending journal contains dependency/structured entries and baseline input identity but no managed-file hashes. PLAN now records the bounded recovery amendment: T4 optional verified ownership receipt input first, T6 planned expected managed-file hashes plus exact confined recovery/caller integration second. Existing task ownership and T4→T6 ordering remain; version1 compatibility is optional-field/conservative. The amendment is under readonly plan review before dispatch. T6 is frozen, with nine focused fixture cases, candidate39, types and fixture lint passing; parent verified /tmp/issue224-t6-stage3-frozen.sha256. Eleven update cases remain unresolved under composed evidence; no fresh319/330 aggregate run is claimed.

T4 verified recovery-input gate passed:26 generation tests, types, inherited scoped lint/format; /tmp/issue224-t4-recovery-input-handoff.md, parent-verified frozen receipt. ScaffoldOutputOptions.verifiedOwnership projects existing receipt types and retains exact config/script/selection/current-byte checks, including absent selection evidence refusal. Ordinary callers keep live-receipt behavior. T6 journal/caller continuation is released to scoped ephemeral session28883; previous native T6 writer is completed and frozen. No concurrent production writer exists.

Current T6 recovery progress (not a final gate): all10 focused recovery cases pass, including exact interrupted retry, modified/missing/escaping evidence guards, old-journal conservatism, and byte-preserving read-only repeat checks. Real local-quality retry also passes without running repository lifecycle scripts. Remaining fixture command-ownership/targeting and refresh-convergence cases are under focused diagnosis; actual native candidate-adoption proof and final coupled/types/lint/format are still required. Source remains owned by session28883.

T6 recovery continuation is frozen and parent-verified:337/338 combined tests pass; the only failure is the already-excluded wiki being newly recorded as a root lint boundary, changing selection/context on repeat. All16 scoped lint/format checks and CLI types pass. Actual candidate-local Oxlint adoption, native local-quality retry and10 recovery/read-only cases pass. Final handoff /tmp/issue224-t6-recovery-final-handoff.md; all32 owned and121 producer hashes verified after session28883 exited. Parent released T4 boundary repair to scoped session24148. Rootless full-publication and targeted old-asset/script retirement remain explicit final T6 evidence gaps after that repair. No A3/T6 completion claim yet.

T4 boundary repair is complete and frozen:32 generation tests, types, lint/format pass; exact two owned,32 T6-owned and121 current producer hashes verified after session24148 exited. Public readback proves selection unchanged and boundaries remain empty. The strict update failure has a separate remaining cause: ContextPlan Commit Gate lint changes from npm run lint -- {files}/files to npm run lint/owner. Locality is existing quality inference in commit-gate/quality.ts:147, which recognizes only the old generated command. Session69045 owns a bounded original T4 convergence repair; no T6 assertion changed. Detailed /tmp/issue224-t4-wiki-boundary-handoff.md and residual-drift JSON preserve both proven boundary repair and unresolved gate drift.

T4 Commit Gate convergence gate passed: validated owner commands now project into the persisted ContextPlan before contract emission, including deferred migration. Generic custom-command inference stays conservative. Four root/app first/second materialization regressions and the unchanged T6 no-op case pass;137 owning tests/types/lint/format are green. Parent verified source and T6 producer receipts after session69045 exited0. T6 final A3 rootless and targeted-retirement evidence is released; no new aggregate338-case pass is claimed.

T6 final A3 witnesses now pass for native rootless adoption (including truthful existing bounded-authoring findings on read-only check), config retirement, owned script fragments, modified/unowned preservation and repeat update. Parent source inspection found that legacy wiki generation also emitted anti-slop sourceFiles; the first retirement fix covered only oxlint.config.ts. Before the cumulative gate, parent froze the completed source/check commands, retained32 current T6 hashes and released session34727 for that remaining plugin-asset case plus final affected validation. This is AC030/OUT017 completion inside original T6 ownership, with no new requirement or public seam. Parent feedback is .devpunks/delivery/issue224/t6-a3-parent-feedback.md; A3 remains open.

Final A3 acceptance

All340 tests pass across the nine-file lifecycle gate, with complete test-ID/multiplicity closure and no missing cases, unexpected skips or duplicate execution. CLI types, inherited scoped lint and format pass. Parent verified32 owned/121 producer hashes before accepting custody. Native interrupted publication now validates its selected owners again even when applied bytes already exist; ownership recovery alone is not current lint proof. Rootless adoption and exact old wiki config/plugin retirement preserve project policy, modified/unowned bytes and repeat/read-only behavior. M1/M2 are removed; RAC-5/A3 pass. Final evidence: /tmp/issue224-t6-a3-final-handoff.md, -final-inventory-closure.json, -final-check-exits.json and -final-preservation.json. One temporary-directory-dependent test title is matched by its documented test ID/source case; product tests and assertions remain unchanged.

T6 skill evidence: tdd applied through retained retirement/native-retry RED/GREEN; codebase-design applied through existing reconciliation and validation-planning seams; quality-types and effect applied through typed observations/errors and passing whole-CLI types; simplify applied by sharing validationChangedPaths between validation need and package planning. T8 now owns final guidance publication/sync; T7 owns final package proof afterward.

Canonical guidance and final package gate

T8/RAC-7 passed: canonical shared-skill main commit 622c4b131bd4193dd3f4d1cc3cc4b10f04c4089a and immutable sync/issue224-managed-lint-622c4b131bd4 pin match the normal sync receipt and all four bundled files.16 wiki tests, content validation and24 link checks pass. Parent verified18 owned file hashes. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t8-final-handoff.md. Writing-for-agents applied through one disclosed managed-lint reference, exact authority paths and observable recovery/health outcomes; HI-REPO-004 and docs/wiki rules pass.

The final T7 build exposed standalone lint argument parsing after the reusable runner is bundled into the host CLI. The original direct-help assertion remains intact; T5 owns the narrow bundle-safe guard repair and T7 reruns generated parity/build/installed package checks afterward. Earlier lifecycle evidence remains valid for lifecycle behavior; full A4 acceptance remains pending the repaired package proof.

T5 final package regression repair is accepted: the standalone entrypoint guard retains the asset filename identity when bundled. Public runManagedLint/executeManagedLintCommand contracts and processing remain unchanged. Actual Bun bundle/Node host RED becomes GREEN; parent independently ran104/104 runner/gate/hook tests and reverified both source hashes. Evidence /tmp/issue224-t5-bundle-final-handoff.md and /tmp/issue224-t5-bundle-adapters.log. T7 is released for final rematerialization/build/tarball proof. This narrow import guard does not invalidate T6 lifecycle behavior; T7 refreshes packaging and adapter execution evidence.

Runtime Validation Evidence

Final T7 commands are retained in /tmp/issue224-t7-final-exits.json: normal build,5 generated parity/dist tests, actual npm-installed package proof, types and scoped quality checks all pass. Tests exercise package/root/npm-workspace CI/gate/edit verification with selected and unselected roots, ordinary-test findings and excluded fixture/wiki source, plus all five canonical/provider hook paths. Installed dist and baseline contain byte-identical neutral modules and execute them. T6 native rootless/install/recovery proof is conclusive in /tmp/issue224-t6-a3-final-handoff.md. Temporary consumers are task-owned; dp-ai remains unchanged. No macOS or full dp-ai CI result is claimed.

Sanity checks

Executed checks: owning T1–T6 suites; final104 adapters; exhaustive340 lifecycle/coupled cases; normal CLI build; final T7 integration5; actual installed npm package; CLI types; scoped lint/format; T8 wiki16/content/24links; exact source sync receipt and byte checks. Counts describe owning suites and are not an additive unique-test total.

UI Evidence Links

Not applicable: no browser UI or visual product behavior changes. CLI/runtime evidence above covers the changed operator surfaces.

Architecture Conformance Evidence

A1–A4 and RAC-1–RAC-7 pass; zero drift from PLAN responsibility topology, declared dependencies and public seams. Settings authority, portable route resolution, policy compilation, shared process execution and existing reconciliation retain distinct owners. Bundle entry activation is now safe without a new execution seam. M1/M2 are removed with exact retirement/preservation/recovery/repeat proof; active migration ledger is empty. PLAN final conformance section links cumulative task proof. No residual in-goal implementation debt remains.

Acceptance Criteria

Final repository-hook audit

Actual pre-commit root lint found an unused accessSync import in the edited-file hook, despite the scoped preset passing. T5 owns removing that unused import without behavior changes; root check and hook tests must pass before T7 refreshes build/package bytes. The first review epoch was stopped before completed coverage or a report; it consumes no completed review ordinal. Actual pre-push still rejects its existing --base argument (/tmp/issue224-final-prepush.log). No hook exception was used.

The root-gate cleanup is complete: unused accessSync removed without behavior changes; root check:repo and43 hook tests pass, exact hash verified (/tmp/issue224-t5-unused-final.md). Actual full pre-commit now reaches456 unchanged wiki errors (/tmp/issue224-final-precommit-after-cleanup.log); pre-push retains the unsupported --base failure. No gates were weakened. T7 refreshes the generated digest and final package proof for the changed hook bytes.

Final cleanup refresh passed: all8 T7 checks exit0 after the unused-import removal, including normal build, integration5/provider hooks and actual installed tarball. Generated bundled digest is 70dd62fbb48a7c0a56439b29db7cabed2f32a57642b8219fd26e16a3cf6b4663; tarball observational SHA is 8a556334c20b82d2da94501f8c0828c14dd5d56d2ff3c21c4319b91cc9f55ff7. Only the expected generated identity changed during the gate;1205 other consumed files stayed fixed. /tmp/issue224-t7-final-handoff.md and final receipts supersede the earlier package bytes. All implementation/acceptance gates are now closed; replacement review and final publication remain.

Independent review finding

The comprehensive primary returned clean Standards, skill-adherence, architecture, simplify and Spec lenses. The independent challenger found runtime boundary scanning recognized package.json while generation also recognized pyproject.toml. Parent accepted issue224-r1 under OUT-004/AC-006: unselected nested projects must be outside ancestor lint/format routing. T2 owns the two-file marker alignment and public RED/GREEN; T7 refreshes generated/installed proof afterward. The complete local report and frozen source archive are /tmp/issue224-review-QIZ26f; publication/retention awaits the final explicit hook exception. No completed retained ordinal is claimed.

Final review repair acceptance

Issue224-r1 is resolved. Runtime discovery now treats pyproject.toml and package.json as nested project boundaries, matching generation and OUT-004/AC-006. T2 retained an actual failing public resolver test before repair, then14 passing tests, types/lint/format and exact source hashes. Parent verified the source receipt and104 refreshed adapter tests. T7 then ran all8 final checks successfully: normal build,5 integration tests, installed npm tarball runtime/byte verification, types, scoped lint, script correctness, formatting and whitespace. Its mixed ordinary-test/pyproject-fixture witness covers package/root/CI, staged Commit Gate and all5 edited-file provider paths without changing either input.

Final bundled digest: dab4640a53ece84f04f89694270a9ee0d5ddbd980550fa06ebb3c7c10e056eca. Final observational tarball SHA256: 8a7697f1e204a661a0b0f4f64a945be752bb213d8ea4a4b9c6a722b6ba586a33. These supersede earlier package bytes. Parent verified all1206 consumed hashes after the gate and the3 owned source hashes. Detailed proof: /tmp/issue224-t2-review-final-handoff.md, /tmp/issue224-review-repair-adapters.log, /tmp/issue224-t7-final-handoff.md and its final receipts. A1/A4, RAC-2/RAC-6 and AC-006 are closed again; all42 criteria and T1–T8 pass. No product or architecture contract changed.

The earlier local review archive remains immutable at /tmp/issue224-review-QIZ26f; its snapshot predates this accepted repair and was never retained, so it establishes no completed ordinal. A fresh replacement review consumes the repaired frozen target. Final remote publication still requires the delivery-specific hook exception for the456 unchanged wiki lint errors and existing unsupported pre-push --base. No exception has been inferred or used.

Final excluded-only review repair

The replacement review returned two verified findings: issue224-r2 (excluded-only edited-file work incorrectly reports selection failure when lint authority is missing/stale) and issue224-r3 (T6 PLAN RED/GREEN fields were empty although the evidence existed). Parent confirmed r2 using16 readonly subprocess cases:12 excluded-only failures across files/preview, missing/stale selection and hard/saved exclusions;4 ordinary-source controls failed as required. All source bytes remained unchanged. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t5-excluded-repro.json. T5 owns the two-file hook repair and must preserve raw managed/settings/shared-policy dependency triggers; T7 owns refreshed generated-provider/package proof.

T6 PLAN now links the retained affected-owner, missing/disabled-selection, input-freshness, legacy-plugin and native-retry RED/GREEN logs plus the final340-case gate. Parent verified every referenced file and the actual failure summaries. This resolves r3 without changing tests, requirements or source behavior. The immutable local report at /tmp/issue224-review-SfpW0P predates r2 repair and remains historical unretained evidence; completed review count remains0. AC-020 and affected packaged proof remain open until the T5/T7 repair gates finish.

Final acceptance after excluded-only repair

Issue224-r2 is resolved without changing raw dependency resolution or successful route handling. Excluded-only source no longer requires JavaScript selection; ordinary source, effective configuration and managed metadata retain their authority checks. Public RED2/GREEN48 hook cases and all109 adapter cases pass, including settings/selection/scaffold-owned policy dependency controls. Types, inherited lint, root checks and formatting pass. Parent verified both frozen T5 source hashes. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t5-excluded-final-handoff.md.

T7 then passed all8 final command gates and5 integration cases, including20 missing/stale-selection × hard/saved-exclusion × generated-provider previews. The normal CLI build and installed npm tarball byte/runtime proof consume the repaired hook. Final bundled digest is 593fd6b39d0cce38920d5e71398464f87c4cd7e35cb0debce4b8fa88030d27a3; observational tarball SHA256 is 53da271efc7700ce9bcc28291067226d117a492e55ebaba1be2201ae7d24b25e. These supersede every earlier package receipt. A test-only lint correction was followed by fresh tests/types/lint/format; prior build/package proof remains applicable because product and package bytes did not change. The final1206-file snapshot accounts for the generated identity and test-style delta; all1204 other inputs stayed unchanged. Parent verified the entire final consumed snapshot and all3 owned T7 source hashes. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t7-final-handoff.md and final receipts.

AC-020, A4 and all42 acceptance criteria are closed. T1–T8 and A1–A4 pass; all3 accepted review findings are repaired with focused proof. No active migration entries or in-goal implementation debt remain. Earlier unretained review snapshots remain historical evidence; the final replacement review must consume these current bytes. Final publication is pending the explicit delivery-specific hook exception only after that report is concrete.

Settings and canonical-alias review repairs

Issue224-r4 is resolved in the existing settings normalizer: safe repeated-separator, leading-dot and trailing-slash exclusion spellings normalize before deterministic deduplication. Existing traversal/absolute/negated-pattern rejection and package eligibility remain unchanged. Actual public settings RED then15 focused settings tests plus saved-byte/runtime compatibility passed, with types/lint/format. Parent verified /tmp/issue224-t1-exclusion-frozen.sha256; proof is /tmp/issue224-t1-exclusion-handoff.md.

Issue224-r5 was narrowed to two real runtime transitions: replacing a previously selected physical owner with a contained wiki/duplicate-owner alias, and explicitly supplying an aliased source that whole-owner enumeration skips. Both reproduced under public resolver RED. Canonical child-owner verification now rejects replacement aliases; explicit source routing matches whole-owner alias exclusion. Canonical repository-root aliases remain supported, and policy/plugin/config dependency resolution is unchanged. All16 resolver tests, types, inherited/root lint and format pass. Parent verified /tmp/issue224-t2-alias-final-handoff.sha256 and reran109 adapter tests after both producers froze. Proof: /tmp/issue224-t2-alias-final-handoff.md, /tmp/issue224-final-alias-adapters.log.

Two advisory premises were rejected after evidence review: T8 was documented as TDD-not-applicable, with16 content-contract tests/24 links/18 verified source hashes; its PLAN fields now make that existing evidence direct. Source-empty packages are supported when local/inherited command/install context exists; existing setup reports unresolved missing package-manager/tool context before adoption, so absence of current JS source does not itself invalidate a Software Scope. No new eligibility requirement was introduced.

The immutable historical report is /tmp/issue224-review-KjQ4Dz. Final T7 package refresh follows these frozen source changes before the replacement report can be retained. All five accepted findings have focused repair proof; package freshness remains the dependent gate.

Final current acceptance and package identity

All five accepted review findings are resolved. Current proof:15 focused settings cases with actual saved-byte/runtime compatibility (in addition to the original32-case T1 gate);16 resolver cases including pyproject and owner/source alias RED/GREEN;109 adapters; the unaffected340-case lifecycle gate; final5 integration cases and all8 build/package/types/lint/format gates. Parent verified the complete1206-file consumed snapshot after the final T7 run and all frozen T1/T2/T7 receipts. All42 criteria, T1–T8 and A1–A4 are closed.

The final bundled digest is 8894decd4b0a3baf113c09f078f63367598ea724d58287c6a81e342cbd086db3; installed archive SHA256 is cda08856bba700e70f98ad2dc7a78bfeb4e6a1e1cea84de648a73466b5957819. These supersede every earlier package receipt above. /tmp/issue224-t7-final-handoff.md records exact final gates and runtime-byte proof. Only the normal generated baseline identity changed during that gate;1205 other consumed inputs stayed unchanged. This is Linux evidence; macOS/full dp-ai CI remain unperformed.

No source implementation work remains. The next steps are the frozen replacement review, its immutable retained report, and final publication using an explicit delivery-specific hook exception if granted. Earlier unretained snapshots and their adjudications remain historical, not completed retained review ordinals. No merge or product release is authorized.

Final native-policy and root-alias acceptance

Issue224-r6 now preserves native Oxlint 1.80 inheritance for both JavaScript and built-in plugins, including omitted, null and empty lists, defaults, relative rebasing and native registration collisions. The public policy suite passes 32 cases with retained RED/GREEN evidence. An independent real-Oxlint comparison produces identical diagnostics and status from native and compiled policy while preserving authored bytes. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t3-native-handoff.md, -evidence.json, -matrix.json, -parity.json and -frozen.sha256.

Issue224-r7 inventories unselected-root check, lint:ci and transitive local aliases through the existing T3 command parser. Noncanonical targets name exact conflicts and preserve manifest, workflow and source bytes; canonical delegation, receipt-owned legacy conversion and rootless behavior remain compatible. The owning generation suite passes 44 cases. Initial worker subprocess restrictions and the new fixture's incomplete projection/structured-state setup were diagnosed separately; the corrected fixture uses the normal compiled state and real ownership capture. Production behavior was not weakened to satisfy the fixture. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t4-root-alias-accepted-handoff.md and matching .sha256.

The current producer refresh passes all 340 lifecycle cases across nine files, with complete test-ID/multiplicity coverage, zero unexpected skips and no missing cases. All production inputs and T6 test files remained frozen; the sole concurrent source-tree change was T4's disjoint generation test fixture. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t6-producer-refresh-inventory-closure.json, -gate-exits.json and -preservation.json.

T7 subsequently passes all eight build/package/types/lint/format command gates and all five generated-entrypoint integration cases. Parent verified the complete 1206-file consumed snapshot and owned receipts. Final bundled digest: 8894decd4b0a3baf113c09f078f63367598ea724d58287c6a81e342cbd086db3. Installed npm archive observational SHA256: 944110f4cca26471fa1ab817086c82509b8c33152f239e4563db64420b34f509. These identities supersede prior package receipts. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-t7-final-handoff.md, -final-exits.json, -final-consumed-after.json and /tmp/issue224-t7-package-evidence-summary.json.

All seven accepted review findings are repaired, all 42 acceptance criteria and A1–A4 pass, and no active migration entries remain. TDD uses public failing behavior before repair; codebase-design retains one policy composer and one script parser; quality-types retains the existing typed policy/generation boundaries. HI-CLI-001/003/004 pass through owning source, native-policy, lifecycle and package proof. T8's exact canonical skill receipt and 18 source hashes still match; HI-REPO-004, HI-WIKI-001/003 and HI-DOCS-001 remain supported by synchronized guidance, registered routes and content/link checks. Unchanged Effect/service behavior requires no new Effect-specific implementation. No architecture ownership or accepted product scope changed.

Linux is the proven runtime; macOS and full dp-ai CI remain unperformed. The final review must consume this frozen implementation and these current receipts. Publication still requires the delivery-specific exception for 456 unchanged wiki lint errors and the unsupported pre-push --base argument. No bypass has been used.

Focused repair after completed review

The completed primary/challenger review of snapshot 06a24e9666e4fdfc722182befd69ea46855ade1a56ca23f325fc452366bb4bbd accepted one additional finding, issue224-r8: direct version-qualified Oxlint CI invocations escaped the bounded inventory. Parent independently reproduced the missing conflicts for npx, bunx and pnpm forms. The skill-evidence candidate was rejected because the required application records exist and retained T6 source-inspection commands corroborate the claimed actions; no separate command-receipt gate is required.

Issue224-r8 is now resolved in the existing CI inventory. Public generation RED captures seven version-qualified command forms failing to produce the required named conflict. GREEN passes all 51 generation cases, preserving exact workflow/command/source bytes and existing setup-flag/quoted-data boundaries. Types, inherited scoped lint, formatting and whitespace checks pass. Evidence: /tmp/issue224-r8-handoff.md, /tmp/issue224-r8-red.log and the handoff's frozen before/after hashes and exact two-file patch. No policy parser, ownership boundary, runtime topology or product contract changed; this is ordinary Focused Repair Validation and does not trigger another full review pass.

The repair was prepared in an isolated checkout while the reviewed implementation/report stayed frozen, then applied only after report retention. T7 refreshed the normal CLI build, five generated-entrypoint integrations, actual installed npm package execution, types/lint/format and source-byte proof against the repaired snapshot. Final installed archive observational SHA256: 8dbcf680c698fc4ee64f0e62e986c47c265731fb07d2f93b37759e317ff4a155. Exact final package evidence: /tmp/issue224-r8-t7-final-handoff.md, -final-exits.json and -package-evidence-summary.json. The earlier 340-case lifecycle proof remains applicable to its unchanged ownership/recovery/source inputs; the CI-inventory correction is covered by current public generation and packaged integration checks.

All eight accepted findings across historical/current review evidence are resolved. All42 acceptance criteria and A1–A4 pass. Canonical guidance already requires known incompatible CI invocations to conflict, so no operator contract rewrite is needed. HI-CLI-001/003 pass via the existing local inventory seam and public proof; TDD, quality-types and codebase-design are applied without new abstractions. Scope remains issue224 only. Linux is proven; macOS/full dp-ai CI remain unperformed. Final publication status and repository-hook exception, if authorized, are recorded in the PR.

Real-repository validation and focused repairs

The user authorized local consumer validation and the remaining path-limited publication exception. Both clones live beneath .devpunks/delivery/issue224/consumer-repos/; no consumer remote was modified. The original frozen CLI SHA256 was 66153eda6c4a612ea8ca8d50a569a0235569ca98f97da58955de6005abccba12. C1/C2 result.md and result.json retain exact argv, working directories, environment overrides, exits and preservation hashes.

Runtime diagnosis reopened two bounded implementation tasks without changing Q1–Q24 or the accepted architecture. C1 root runner checked stale selection before recognizing an explicit excluded-only request; the edited-file hook already skipped that work. C2 traced38 scheduled dependency retirements to missing candidate manifests across eight former owners: valid live JSON was absent from the sparse candidate. Evidence lives in ci-app-evidence/suspected-excluded-only-defect.json and devpunks-intelligence-evidence/debug-candidate.ndjson. C2 is repaired with182 owning tests, focused retirement/containment cases, and a real update lifecycle witness. The first rebuilt C1 rerun closes excluded-only failures but exposed a root-policy applicability control when adopted routes are empty; its follow-up remains in the same resolver ownership. Final rebuilt consumer results below govern closure.

The first C2 repaired adoption completed241 managed writes and eliminated all38 missing-manifest failures. Root/owner diagnostics were identical (231 findings), edited-file preview matched its corresponding direct route, and real excluded/nested paths remained untouched. The candidate's false clean result was separately reproduced with real Oxlint: its command listed only config/manifest inputs while the live command also listed selected source. Runtime proof rules out different config or a lost diagnostic: identical config/tool plus absent source yielded zero findings; including the selected owner yielded the same no-debugger finding as live. Candidate preparation and source fingerprinting now distinguish selected lint owners from ancestor installation roots. The final rebuild and real-consumer parity rerun remain the final validation gate.

C1's root-policy control led to a conservative migration-input veto from existing named conflict evidence, including renamed policy and manifest fragments. The edited-file hook's redundant excluded-source failure suppression was removed after the shared resolver gained the no-work proof. Known excluded policy inputs now retain validation failures; ordinary excluded source remains clean.140 public resolver/runner/hook/gate tests, actual RED/GREEN, types and scoped checks pass (/tmp/issue224-hook-final-handoff.md). No second config/discovery authority was introduced.

Final source integration closes the loader diagnostic regression without weakening the missing-selection assertion: ENOENT settings use an empty selection input, while explicit JSON null remains invalid.141 resolver/runner/hook/gate tests and183 runtime/candidate/validation-plan tests pass on current inputs. The normal build, five generated-entrypoint/build tests, installed tarball execution/byte proof and full CLI type check pass. The final binary is 83c7f74151af023cde4a86faaa637a2b5b32b7632531596696f60de580bc76b7; bundled digest d6b8474d674c8f68c40be34eff090042a28eb37eae9301388df733e17d003cb7; npm archive SHA256 11b8cd5c32faedf227d7a9898c6ff7f6381682b407fea4d5fa8edb223fdbb934. All1,206 consumed inputs stayed frozen except the expected normal-build identity refresh.

Root static verification passes in a detached worktree containing HEAD plus the exact tracked diff and linked workspace dependencies (/tmp/issue224-final-static-worktree-result.json): root lint/format and all34 cache/topology checks pass. The in-place attempt traversed the user-requested untracked consumer clones and failed on their code; an initial archive-only snapshot also lacked Git metadata/workspace dependencies. Neither failed attempt is called a passing gate. An additional broad legacy bun run lint invocation reported errors outside the focused runtime repair; required explicit-config scoped lint passes, and no full-CLI lint success is claimed. Existing full precommit wiki findings and unsupported pre-push argument remain covered only by the user's scoped publication exception.

The final C1 supported scaffold refresh and28 actual runner/edit-preview checks all pass expected outcomes, including root migration-policy and mixed-input controls. All159 critical original consumer files remain unchanged. Evidence: ci-app-evidence/final-verification.json and final-entrypoints.json. C1 remains deliberately unadopted because its existing policies/commands conflict, and its declared-toolchain frozen install fails.

Final C2 rerun passes with the same frozen binary: the normal one-owner update applies241 files and candidate validation reports231 findings, matching both live owner and root commands. The returned candidate finding sample matches live diagnostics; the single-file edited preview matches its direct route; real wiki/CV exclusions produce no work. All5,580 recorded file/symlink hashes match after restoration. Evidence: devpunks-intelligence-evidence/final-verification.json, logs90–96, and retained final adoption diff/archive. This closes the candidate source-coverage discrepancy. It proves the deliberately migrated one-owner experiment, not blanket adoption of the original nine-owner conflicting repository. Original authored policies remain unchanged in the restored clone.

All42 acceptance criteria and T1–T8/A1–A4 are reconciled and closed by the retained original evidence plus these focused repairs. The shared resolver owns exclusions/authority applicability; candidate preparation owns planned mutation inputs and selected source; installation roots remain separate. No accepted requirement, architecture, authorization boundary or deployment topology changed, so the completed review ordinal remains1 and ordinary focused validation applies. At that pre-CI checkpoint there were no unresolved implementation findings; the current CI repair status above supersedes delivery-complete claims pending failure adjudication and full validation. Remaining real-repository migration conflicts, C1 frozen-lockfile failure, and Linux-only/full-application-CI limits are reported rather than treated as completed adoption. HI-CLI-001/003/004 and HI-DOCS-001/HI-WIKI-001/003 pass with current owning checks, final packaged bytes, preserved authored files, and synchronized content. Canonical skill receipt remains unchanged; no new release product is selected.