Delivery phase handoff

Phase: closeout Status: closeout Scope: Deliver GitHub issue #204 on team/stefan/issue-204-portable-commit-gates, stacked directly on issue #203. Artifacts: SPEC.md, PLAN.md, IMPLEMENTATION-NOTES.md, requirements grill log/status, and research report in this branch. Validation: The child began at original issue #203 head 7357f43b686f4866e45925f875e458e8c29ef6f3, fast-forwarded to 2d8839978075419cb9a8a70f296f078626d31a7d, and was subsequently rebased through the moving stack to current PR #208 head d50fe8b6a63cea52db6a2ff56e2c9b42868ef79d; git merge-base --is-ancestor passed. PR #208 is open with head fix/issue-203-scaffold-convergence and base team/stefan/release-issues-203-207. Plan review findings were repaired; Fumadocs MDX generation passed. Review/debug/docs state: Review pass 1 returned bounded implementation and docs-ingest findings; repair 1 completed them. Review pass 2 found terminal-CR path truncation and silent linked-worktree Git cleanup failure; repair 2 test-drove terminal-LF-only handling, hardened cleanup reporting, refreshed the bundled digest, and passed focused validation. Current review state: Retained review 1 found one low-severity acceptance-evidence mismatch: the linked-worktree fixture omitted the stale legacy root claimed by implementation notes. Repair 1 added that obsolete absolute root to the linked-worktree contract and passed the focused runner suite 9/9. Retained review 2 is clean across Standards, skill adherence, architecture, simplify, Spec, and structured autoreview. Retained review 3 found only i204-sa-001; docs ingest repaired the T2 TDD label to not_applicable for coverage-only evidence. No fourth review or debt is required. UI Evidence: Not applicable; CLI-only behavior. Next suggested route: Complete closeout validation, push the existing child PR with lease protection, and verify the live 203 → 204 stack. Blockers: None. The prior commit-hook authority blocker is resolved by explicit user authorization.

Resolved commit-hook handback

• Initial goal and accepted bounds: Deliver issue #204 on team/stefan/issue-204-portable-commit-gates, stacked on PR #208, without Astra subagents and without publication, version, or changelog changes.
• Last known-good state: Rebased commits aefaba02 and e4bf7f83 contain the issue #204 implementation and repair 3. Post-rebase validation passed 28/28 focused tests, CLI typecheck, changed-file formatting, CLI build, wiki content sync, Fumadocs generation, and git diff --check.
• Attempts and evidence: Normal commit attempts were run with default and private TMPDIR. Both reached the repository hook and failed on inherited checks: 497 pre-existing wiki lint errors plus unrelated scaffold/config baseline diagnostics. No hook was bypassed.
• Blocker and effect: The seven pending files cannot be committed normally, preventing a complete push, retained review report, release classification against the final commit, and correctly based child PR.
• Proposed next action: Authorize one git commit --no-verify for the exact pending issue #204 files only. Existing focused validation remains the evidence gate; no unrelated files would be included.
• Why authority changes: --no-verify weakens a repository commit gate, so delivery autonomy cannot infer permission.
• Exact human decision and outcome: The user approved bypassing the hook for the exact pending issue #204 commit. The validated repair commit was created with --no-verify, rebased onto PR #208 head 72a6ccf5e1a8861d5effb52db941c9860109d00f, and amended only for bounded review-evidence corrections.

Resolved handback history

This historical blocker was resolved when the user supplied PR #208. It is retained only as provenance and does not require current action.

• Initial goal and accepted bounds: Implement and validate issue #204 on a new child branch based directly on issue #203, preserving the 203 → 204 PR stack, without Astra subagents.
• Last known-good state: Requirements confirmed; local agent-ready spec compiled; execution-ready plan reviewed; Wave W1 is ready but undispatched; current branch remains unchanged at the required parent commit plus planning artifacts.
• Attempts and evidence: gh pr list for both heads returned no PR. A paginated direct GitHub REST query across all PR states returned no entry whose head is fix/issue-203-scaffold-convergence or whose title/body identifies issue #203.
• Blocker and effect: implement-spec treats a missing intended parent PR as a blocker before implementation. It prevents worker dispatch and later creation of the correctly based child PR.
• Proposed next action: Create one normal PR for remote branch fix/issue-203-scaffold-convergence targeting main, then resume implementation and eventually create the issue #204 PR with that parent head branch as its base.
• Why authority changes: The proposed action creates a separate PR for issue #203, which is external provider mutation outside the current issue #204 branch run. The implementation invariant explicitly forbids silently creating another PR to repair a missing parent.
• Historical decision that was required: Authorize creating the issue #203 parent PR or provide the intended existing parent PR. Resolved by the supplied PR #208.

state: closeout delivery_goal_identity: github-issue-204-portable-commit-gates accepted_bounds_identity: issue-204-spec-2026-09-15 accepted_bounds_hash: 5b94d020668e865bca3672d7f0096814903b1e4010a83094a806315feb4e0511 review_lineage_id: 18f689275d3b9d8264787f2646f3f0802fd2092f3254852bc0d822c22a787d37 review_run_id: 372c46f595b1a12e3e95baf91ca8596880937cf61e144ccbf61c459a8adffbdf review_count: 3 repair_count: 2 authoritative_report_path: apps/wiki/content/docs/project/reviews/review-18f689275d3b9d826478-20260915T140148Z-8fbaee5b1080-review-report.md authoritative_report_sha256: 933279c86e72f959ba9f507c1fdaef6fc0a3676e00fce2377445e190fe59ddd5 authoritative_report_commit: 1e6e0d556082599015822266e5841eda0059f923 source_set_hash: c9a8a045635b92ef11da65ad9ba5ce03a61b511da24d62e0e396c0e4f96db44f snapshot_hash: 8fbaee5b108001c376396f55f986cfc1c0c20860885421cff0266e666a677622 stable_finding_ids: [i204-sa-001] resolved_finding_ids: [i204-sa-001] secondary_architecture_follow_up: false verified_retained_ref: team/stefan/issue-204-portable-commit-gates review_invocation_authority: full_delivery review_invocation_skill: $review-phase review_invocation_mode: delivery recovered_review_count: 3 primary_route: docs_ingest current_route: closeout normalized_target: git-diff:d50fe8b6a63cea52db6a2ff56e2c9b42868ef79d..32aa1831455058f3f01868c2de650c8aae40d460+worktree normalized_target_kind: delivery-git-diff normalized_target_scope_count: 22 normalized_target_patch_hash: 1e07ca13da9c50649b09df5b13ffe6505c75722fa6fc5e7c5bb19af5db96fec5

Resume evidence

• Observed parent PR: https://github.com/wearedevpunks/harness-intelligence/pull/208
• Verified stack edge: fix/issue-203-scaffold-convergence → team/stefan/issue-204-portable-commit-gates
• Implementation state: Waves W1 and W2 and their historical repairs are committed and validated. Retained review 3's sole documentation finding, i204-sa-001, is repaired through docs ingest; no fourth review or debt is required.
• Review boundary: Snapshot 8fbaee5b108001c376396f55f986cfc1c0c20860885421cff0266e666a677622 is the immutable historical review snapshot. The final delta corrects T2's coverage-only status and closeout evidence, and preserves remote commit ecb4e10b39309ee6c2e92c70cf018bc64d79b349's preloaded-alias wiki fix in place of the reviewed fallback configuration. Focused validation and the full wiki production build pass for that final configuration.

Closeout validation

• Focused executable acceptance: runner and scaffold output suites pass 28/28.
• CLI gates: typecheck passes; lint exits successfully with inherited warnings and no errors; all four changed CLI files pass focused formatting; the CLI build passes and retains bundled digest 23ddfddfc140e560f076d57c4f98b20ab0368aeea03861a447c16b4fb869de99 for 825 assets.
• Docs gates: current full wiki production build and wiki content check pass; the ingest log remains capped at 50 entries.
• Release classification: prior evidence is releaseKind: none, baselinePublicationRequired: false, and npmPublicationRequired: false; parent-owned final classification remains pending.
• Review: retained pass 3 found only i204-sa-001; this docs-ingest repair records T2's coverage-only TDD status as not_applicable. No fourth review or follow-up debt is required.
• Debugging: PR #210's Vercel deployment now succeeds with rehypeCodeDefaultOptions spread, explicit json and shellscript preloads, and review-report-json aliased to json. This replaces the superseded fallback-language claim.
• UI Evidence: not applicable for this CLI-only change.

Next: parent performs final formatting, release-none check, push, and provider stack/deployment readback.