Work log

Spec retained in commit 4d61376abe20c88a955e8670a8d6d65a44fce410 and verified by remote branch and immutable GitHub contents readback. Full delivery authorized. Plan review completed. Entries below preserve chronological evidence; the latest gate and acceptance records govern.

Backlog: planning-only execution; GitHub issues #200/#201/#219/#220 are the existing requested closeout records. No Linear mutation or provider Task projection claimed.

Validation environment: frozen Bun install failed on untouched base with Bun 1.3.9 and 1.3.5. Bun 1.3.5 install --ignore-scripts --no-save succeeded without tracked lockfile/manifest changes. Explicit prepare patched Effect/Oxlint successfully. Git hooks reported absent Lefthook configuration in isolated checkout; no hook success claimed. Local checks run explicitly.

Activated rule audit

Current task-local audit; final runtime evidence and review are recorded below when complete.

• HI-CLI-001: pass. Detection, candidate composition, local update publication and Git commit checks remain CLI-owned; no control-plane behavior or dependency moved. Runtime/producer/public contract tests pass.
• HI-CLI-003: pass. New validation selection belongs to CLI features; packaged runners remain in data; shared optional execution metadata remains in scaffold schemas. Owning types, tests and T7 final caller proof pass.
• HI-CLI-004: pass. Projection/core/authoring/lint-feedback tests (6), public scaffold tests (7), packaged-validator tests (17), generated output tests and runtime tests (160) pass. Normal build and post-build types pass; frozen runner bytes match source and all 11 shipped-runner scenarios pass. Generated-contract warning proof passes against the same frozen distribution.
• HI-SCAFFOLD-001: pass. Optional strict execution metadata is a pure shared model; no filesystem/platform import introduced. Four contract suites (62 tests), public scaffold contract (7 tests) and current scaffold types pass.
• HI-WIKI-001 / HI-WIKI-003: pass for current docs. Spec route is linked from CLI metadata; runbook projection/content checks pass, with 8 Node, 1 Bun and 12 Vitest wiki tests. Final review report navigation/content will be checked after retention.
• HI-DOCS-001: pass. Implemented workflow lives in canonical docs/runbooks/hi-cli-scaffolding.md, linked by docs/README.md; wiki copy is synchronized. Product intent remains in the accepted specification.
• HI-REPO-001: not-applicable. Shared scaffold model changes do not alter remote API, client, callback, storage or secret contracts; both schema and packaged decoder consumers are covered by owning tests.
• HI-REPO-003: not-applicable. Docs changes add no application URL/origin/callback; no local endpoint changed.
• HI-REPO-004: not-applicable to source synchronization. Only project-owned verifier references/helpers change under the explicit update-verification-skill contract. Reusable SKILL.md and packaged skill trees are unchanged.
• HI-UI-001: not-applicable. Wiki content and metadata change; no UI component, style or composition change.
• HI-CLI-002 / HI-REPO-002: not-applicable. No changelog, package version, publication entrypoint or release publication changes. Final release classification remains required.
• Remaining registry entries: not-applicable; API, backoffice, web, auth, config, contract, database and env owned paths/behavior are unchanged.

Delivery handoff

Mode: full delivery. Current phase: closeout. Retained review and focused repair complete; final provider readback recorded in delivery handoff. User explicitly chose an unmerged PR ready for review. Issues remain open with closing references until merge. Hosted CI is suppressed because Blacksmith quota is exhausted; all commits use [skip ci]. Original repositories are never write targets.

Dispatch and plan review

• T1 candidate_runtime_fix: runtime composition, closure/parser, explicit lint target adapter.
• T2 generation_freshness_fix: generation snapshot owner.
• T3 quality_contract_fix: shared schema.
• T4 repository_quality_settings: CLI settings persistence.
• plan-reviewer verified disjoint W1; added T1→T6 and T5→T7 to preserve stable test inputs, generated-path ownership for T8, explicit managed/schema/real-Oxlint gates, and Effect guidance.
• candidate_dependency_audit retains real pinned Oxlint semantics evidence using isolated fixtures only.
• No hosted workflow runs found for the pushed spec branch.

Passed task gates

T3: public schema RED→GREEN; 62 tests in four package suites, scaffold typecheck, formatting, focused lint pass. Two untouched warning locations remain; package-wide lint has pre-existing unrelated errors. No runtime owner moved. Evidence t3-contract-red.log, t3-package-tests.log, t3-typecheck.log, t3-focused-lint.log. Parent source/evidence inspection passed.

T4: settings persistence RED→GREEN, malformed authority RED→GREEN, 12 total tests, CLI typecheck and focused lint pass. Existing settings migration choices preserved. Evidence t4-red.log, t4-invalid-red.log, t4-final-tests.log, t4-types.log, t4-lint.log and t4-handoff.md. Parent source/evidence inspection passed.

T5 is now ready for dispatch after T3/T4; T6 waits T1, T7 waits T1/T2/T5. T1 has archive RED→GREEN but parser/composition remain pending. T2 is refining snapshot selection and explicit import closure; not passed.

AC003 real-runtime witness: 24 invocations using installed Oxlint 1.80.0/Ultracite 7.10.7 pass five matching path classes, preserved unrelated rule, ordinary source equality, synthetic two-override scope and downstream precedence. Reproduce with node ../evidence/ac003-runtime/witness.mjs. Full generator-to-parser integration remains T1.

Tooling note: source tool outputs are sometimes lossy. Print command output as numbered source-line records (see ../evidence/source-read-tip.md) for exact reads. Current runtime worker reported needing reliable source transport; no concurrent runtime owner exists.

Continuation task gates and runtime custody

Previous goal turn classified progress: T3/T4 implementation and proof completed, spec retained remotely. T1 validator gate now passed: 36 tests including generated backoffice output, negative callback/special-input closure; source review supports bounded grammar. Composition explicitly not claimed.

T2 gate returned to repair: initial change omitted the modern timestamp-directory/snapshot.json layout explicitly reported in #220 and retained no concrete Unclosed detail. Scoped repair process session 79613 owns only its two generation files.

T5 and T10 run as scoped Codex CLI worker processes (sessions 55208 and 5347). Native collaboration control availability was intermittent; local worker subprocesses preserve exact scopes, read-only shared dependencies, and retained events/results. All three live process handles polled successfully. No original checkouts or shared service configuration changed.

Authoritative CLI typecheck is bun run --cwd apps/cli check-types; package.json:29 invokes pinned native tsc. Earlier abbreviated package output omitted it; the plan now uses verified command.

Current continuation

Warm continuation: branch/base/spec identities match retained authority. T3/T4 remain passed. T10 owns both runtime script and validator files exclusively after T1 stopped edits; final composition gate pending. T2 modern-snapshot repair passed 32 tests, but real Collective probe still fails reference-escape in imported Vite runtime; same scoped worker resumed with exact evidence (session 24378). T5 parent inspection identified unconfined detector settings I/O and missing read-only validation of declared format commands; gate requires repair before dependent release. T6/T7 remain dependency-blocked, not omitted.

Draft PR #222 created from pushed spec HEAD 4d61376abe20c88a955e8670a8d6d65a44fce410 targeting main. Provider readback confirms draft/open, all four closing references, zero GitHub Actions runs, and skipped codesmith check. Existing Vercel integration checks are separate provider statuses. Evidence: pr-222-initial-readback.json and pr-222-initial-runs.json. PR attached to the task. Product changes remain uncommitted; no issue closure or implementation completion claimed.

Original checkouts: all task writes remain inside isolated worktrees. Harness matches initial preservation manifest. Collective has concurrent pre-existing/user-owned state changes; do not revert them or claim byte-identical status. Final preservation audit will distinguish that external delta.

Integration wave

T2 parent gate passed: removed unsupported generic import traversal after actual producer-reader audit; 39 tests, full CLI types, scoped lint/format, and real Harness/Collective Closed probes. Exact source hashes match t2-producer-after.sha256. Detailed handoff recovered unchanged from the worker's retained tool write as t2-producer-handoff.md because its final-output path replaced the original handoff text. Earlier Vite-only/parser and import-consumption claims are superseded.

T5 producer gate passed after two repairs: 140 tests across five suites, types, scoped lint/format, 384 stable input hashes. Known mutating repository format commands reject; detector no longer reads settings. Caller wiring is explicitly assigned to T7 update/platform paths, with t5-repair-parent-wiring.patch as evidence, and remains an integrated acceptance obligation. Existing no-session settings I/O is pre-existing; this task introduces no detector read.

T10 gate passed: parent ran all 160 runtime/validator tests, zero skipped, with four unchanged source hashes. Its socket test passed using TMPDIR=/tmp from the parent; previous worker workspace-write restriction is not a current blocker. Type, lint, format checks retained; runtime scopes frozen. See t10-final-handoff.md and t10-parent-full*.json/.log.

T6 runner and T7 update/platform integration dispatched as disjoint scoped CLI workers. T6 session 95113; T7 handle in tool receipt. Parent verified global/project settings and manifest specialists; native control exposure was intermittent, so retained CLI process workers used. Source reader task recent_update_regressions completed readonly audit. No full Code Review pass yet.

User explicitly selected leaving PR #222 ready for review, and continuing implementation. Do not merge. Keep the four verified closing references; issue closure occurs on merge. This latest instruction supersedes any assumption that full delivery should merge now.

Final integration continuation

T6 accepted for integration: 26 real Git/process tests pass, successful output is preserved once on original streams, explicit authority covers deletions/renames/root changes. Inputs remained stable. Forced type-aware MJS lint is non-clean (139 current errors versus 101 baseline); normal test lint and runner syntax checks pass. No lint config or suppression changed. See external evidence t6-handoff.md.

T11 packaged validator repair accepted at its local gate: optional execution metadata matches the shared schema; 17 tests, syntax, normal scoped checks pass. Source SHA-256 9b59af669ecd3386bc449b0f4e53ffa87ba17aa3bfa58cc6a5489023bdf77669. Normal checks exclude this MJS; forced diagnostic scan has five added unsafe-access/argument diagnostics amid existing debt. Integration/build identity remains T8-owned. See t11-handoff.md.

T12 aligns exactly two generated lint expectations to oxlint --max-warnings 0; custom command remains unchanged. Owning five tests, scoped lint/format pass. Source SHA-256 1ff517e518b087215fc48d8940ba27e65cb9ea64c8a643bdc91020ef8e2099a6. See t12-handoff.md; original RED retained in t8-output-tests.log.

Concurrent automatic CLI PostToolUse format hooks rewrote T11 source during T6/T7 execution. Parent retained exact contaminated bytes and hook-state evidence, stopped the old T7 session, and resumed with process-only hooks disabled. T11 restored only the intended narrow patch after clearance. Nineteen previously validated dependency files remained unchanged (t8-dependency-hash-audit.json). No project/global hook setting or service changed.

Parent integration: public scaffold contract 7 pass; projection/core/authoring/lint-feedback 6 pass; output/reconciliation 38 pass plus the two T12 expectations now green. Wiki content check and generated-source setup pass; wiki 8 Node, 1 Bun, and 12 Vitest tests pass. Prepared project verifier references await the frozen built CLI; no built-runtime success claimed yet.

Pnpm owning-installation follow-through

Parent input-wiring probe showed pnpm-only workspace declarations were omitted by update planning. A child using workspace:/catalog: dependencies consequently had no installation owner. T7 owns the bounded repair: extract the existing pure pnpm workspace parser, feed it confined caller reads, and retain a caller RED/GREEN plus malformed-config diagnostics. This implements the accepted owning-installation requirement; it adds no package-manager policy or feature scope. Existing full gate continues unchanged before the repair.

Architecture and presentation

Local change. Existing CLI runtime, update, generation observer, settings, producer and packaged runner seams retain ownership. Shared scaffold adds optional schema metadata only. No service boundary moves or temporary migration layer. UI Evidence: not applicable; no UI behavior changed.

Managed changes -> affected consumers/installations -> final candidate checks -> publication
Staged Git changes -> explicit command coverage -> original-stream diagnostics and exit status

The parent uses this view for the assigned show-me guidance. The final acceptance table and retained report, rather than this diagram, establish completion.

Manual Review Checklist

Runtime setup observations

Installed CLI 5.1.1 passed its version Doctor, but a fresh bundled scaffold fixture failed before generation because frameworks/nestjs/nestjs-best-practices/.gitignore is missing from the installed asset tree. This pre-existing packaging limitation is retained in old-fixture-setup; the installed CLI is unchanged. Final fresh fixtures use the complete built distribution. Existing Harness and Collective consumers use independent Git clones at the recorded bases, so real hook installation cannot write a shared main-worktree Git directory.

T7 full-gate findings

The stable-input full gate completed in 2,772 seconds: 80 passed, 7 failed across 5 files. It covered update, validation planning and scoped scaffold operation. The 7 failures concern interrupted/repeated publication, missing authored guidance/wiki recovery, managed Oxlint catalog repair, and lifecycle hook/receipt installation. T7 remains repair-required; no completion or review-ready claim is made from this run. All 1,204 captured source inputs were stable. A focused public pnpm caller RED independently confirms missing pnpm workspace ownership before preview. Evidence: t7-closeout-final-tests.log, its before/after/result manifests, and t7-pnpm-caller-red.log.

Focused repair frontier after full T7 gate

T2 reopened under its original generation snapshot owner after new public recovery evidence: live dangling managed CLAUDE mirrors block generation freshness before final candidate repair. Exclusive write scope remains its two generation-inputs files. Producer reader provenance determines treatment; no blanket acceptance of Unclosed input is allowed. T7 independently owns pnpm caller/detector and managed-artifact selection repairs. Coordinate writes around relevant-input snapshots; changed dependencies invalidate affected checks. Evidence: t2-mirror-repair-request.md, t7-closeout-failure-diagnostics.log, t7-pnpm-caller-red.log, t7-skill-template-red.log. T8 build/runtime and T9 review remain dependent.

T2 managed-mirror gate passed: exact canonical output mirrors witness their link text while authored AGENTS inputs remain independently required. Producer provenance and required-alias/copied-asset negatives are retained; final candidate validation is unchanged. Three public observer RED cases became GREEN, full generation suite 46 passes; types/scoped lint/format pass. Parent verified source hashes against t2-managed-mirror-handoff.md. Integrated recovery remains T7-owned; any overlapping source snapshots are invalidated and rerun.

Skill Application Evidence

Each record preserves the exact PLAN guidance. Loaded records remain pending application acceptance; task completion and runtime evidence govern promotion. T7 readiness testing retains its disclosed recovered ordering deviation.

Focused integration repair gate

The stable 13-case run passed 11 and failed two after 600 seconds. Catalog repairs, missing wiki/root recovery, pnpm caller, handoff-only publication, four readiness negatives, and lifecycle binary/hook recovery are now proven in that run. Remaining: interrupted shared publication still returns planned; the foreign-hook first-publication assertion was mistakenly changed alongside the repeated no-op expectation and must be restored to succeeded. No completion claim. Evidence: t7-repair-final-focused-green-result.json (1,204 stable inputs), corresponding log, and t7-final-two-parent-findings.md.

The final interruption diagnostic identifies .codex/AGENTS.md, another exact generated shared prompt mirror; Codex/OpenCode adapters both declare these outputs from .agents/AGENTS.md. T2 resumes its same two-file scope to apply the existing output-link witness to those exact projections. T7 final foreign-hook first/repeat case now passes. Evidence: t2-other-prompt-mirror-hypothesis.md, t7-repair-last-diagnostic.log. This extends documented producer provenance; required aliases and final candidate closure remain mandatory.

T2 provider-mirror correction passed: two additional public observer RED cases, all 48 generation tests GREEN, full CLI types and scoped lint/format pass. Only exact .codex/AGENTS.md and .opencode/AGENTS.md links to ../.agents/AGENTS.md join the existing output witness seam. Source hashes verified against t2-provider-mirror-handoff.md; T7 integrated interruption rerun remains pending.

T7 accepted gate

All seven original failures resolved. Final retained coverage: 31 selection/detector/platform tests; 13 public cases covered by the stable 11-pass run plus foreign-hook and final interruption passes. Final interruption check passed with all 1,204 inputs stable; final types, scoped lint (zero errors/130 warnings) and format pass. Parent verifies final owned hashes against t7-final-owned-sha256.json. No full post-repair 87-test rerun is claimed. Readiness TDD remains recovered/deviation; no fabricated historical RED. T8 normal build and frozen executable proof released.

Final implementation acceptance audit

Normal build and post-build CLI types pass. Runtime proof uses the copied, immutable distribution in ../frozen-dist, Node 22.22.0, SPEC SHA-256 1920f5920e08b465bf6f8a3f546750b5b256f52bc84b19d9886f1f076c13cc7b, and frozen-runtime-identity.json. Product sources, distribution and Node stayed unchanged during the probes. Parent-owned build changed only the generated baseline identity relative to the final integration snapshot.

Evidence: candidate-cli-handoff.md, candidate-cli-final-result.json, each candidate-cli-*/verification.json, t8-effect-vitest-actual/summary.json, ac003-runtime/, t8-commit-final-handoff.md, t8-commit-coverage-final/result.json, t8-generated-warning/result.json, t8-final-build.log, t8-built-types.log. Runtime-owned fixtures and caches are removed with evidence retained outside scratch.

Validation limits

This is targeted local validation, not a green hosted CI or full post-repair integration-suite claim. The original 87-test integration run had 80 passes and seven failures; all seven were resolved with stable focused checks, including 31 selection/detector/platform tests, 11 passing public cases plus separate foreign-hook/interruption passes. The readiness TDD ordering deviation remains disclosed. Normal scoped checks pass with existing warnings. Forced MJS type-aware diagnostics retain baseline debt and added unsafe diagnostics; no config or suppression was changed to conceal them. Frozen dependency installation failed on the untouched base; isolated no-save installation and explicit Effect preparation established tooling without lockfile edits.

Fresh candidate fixtures retain 1,631 ordinary generated-file lint findings; the Effect fixture retains 9,790. These are advisory update-preview findings, not operational failure or a lint-clean claim. The strict generated commit gate is independently proved to fail on warnings.

Real consumer clones did not complete upgrades: Harness reached actual validation but Oxlint rejected simultaneous legacy and generated configs; Collective stopped on recorded context-plan drift after genuine missing scaffold metadata was restored. Both retained zero writes and no completed apply. These consumer-state limitations and the installed 5.1.1 missing bundled NestJS asset are recorded in t8-real-consumer-assessment.md and are outside this issue implementation. Original Harness matches initial bytes/status; Collective has concurrent tracked work from another task, so byte equality is not claimed. Neither original was a write target.

Architecture closure

No ownership migration or compatibility wrapper remains. Candidate composition/closure belongs to CLI runtime; generation freshness witnesses actual producer inputs; the update feature selects affected installation/lint scopes; scaffold owns pure optional contract metadata; the packaged runner interprets explicit authority. Existing public seams cover each responsibility. Migration ledger: empty.

Managed change -> affected installation/lint -> composed candidate -> guarded publication
Staged Git change -> explicit coverage -> unchanged command -> diagnostics and exit

The code is ready for T9 review. PR remains unmerged; issue closure and published CLI availability are separate future states.

Retained review and focused repair

Review count1, repair count1. Report commit 93a002e81a8f746e09ef48dd173f278b7788d3f9 retains complete primary and independent challenger coverage. Primary lenses were clean; the parent accepted challenger finding pr222-r1: update caller omits optionalDependencies when constructing affected-consumer edges, although repository discovery recognizes them. AC-004 is reopened for this narrow case.

The existing T7 owner corrects caller extraction and proves the actual update seam RED/GREEN. T8 uses a new immutable build for affected CLI proof; previous source/dist evidence remains unchanged and applies to unaffected behavior. This is an omitted dependency category within the accepted model, with no architecture, security, public-contract, runtime-topology or scope change. Delivery policy requires focused validation and no second full review.

Focused repair implementation gate

pr222-r1 source repair passed parent review: optionalDependencies joins existing dependency sections; no other product behavior changed. The new public update regression first converges a scaffold, changes only shared configuration, and asserts optional consumer selection, its independent installation, the owning root workspace installation and exclusion of an unrelated consumer. Genuine RED omitted the optional consumer; final GREEN passes two caller tests, ten planner tests and five existing helper safety tests. Types, scoped lint/format and diff checks pass. Earlier fixture-isolation failures remain classified as setup diagnostics.

Normal build and post-build CLI types pass. New freeze: ../frozen-dist-r1, pr222-r1-runtime-identity.json. Compared with the first freeze, only update/run.ts and its test changed in product sources; distribution changes are the executable plus baseline identity/archive metadata. Baseline payloads, commit runner, generation logic, schemas, settings and validator sources remain byte-identical. Previous freeze is preserved. Unaffected prior runtime/module proof remains applicable; actual optional-consumer CLI validation is the remaining focused gate. Evidence: pr222-r1-handoff.md, final input/hash records and pr222-r1-runtime-delta.json.

Final focused repair acceptance and closeout

pr222-r1 resolved. Rebuilt CLI positive update runs exactly one root installation and two lint scopes (packages/shared, apps/optional-consumer); observed real process working directories and the optional consumer's no-eval diagnostic prove it was validated. Publication succeeds with only shared config/manifest changes. The independent negative names apps/optional-consumer/tsconfig.json and missing ./required-missing.tsconfig.json, exits nonzero before install/lint, has no completed apply and leaves the whole tree unchanged. Source/distribution/Node identities match the new freeze; owned scratch and caches are cleaned with external evidence retained.

Evidence: pr222-r1-candidate-handoff.md, pr222-r1-candidate-final-result.json, positive/negative verification manifests, pr222-r1-handoff.md, pr222-r1-runtime-identity.json, pr222-r1-runtime-delta.json. AC-004 is now passed including optional consumers. All AC-001–AC-008 implementation obligations are satisfied; final PR/CI/issue readbacks are in the external delivery handoff.

One full primary/challenger review is retained, with one accepted finding and one completed focused repair. No outstanding finding or architecture migration remains. No second full review was triggered: correction adds an already-supported dependency category without changing public contracts, ownership, authorization or runtime topology. Unaffected proof remains applicable by exact source/payload comparison.

Docs ingest verified existing canonical runbook, docs index and byte-identical wiki projection; no further prose change needed for this repair (pr222-r1-docs-ingest.json). No UI surface changed. Debugging-phase was unnecessary: the retained finding was a source selection omission repaired through the implementation route; runtime failures were preserved as fixture/consumer-state diagnostics.

Full review -> optional-consumer finding -> focused correction -> real CLI proof -> PR ready
                                                                                     |
                                                                      human review/merge -> issues close

User chose the PR-ready boundary. No merge, issue closure before merge, release publication or installed CLI replacement. Release selection remains none because neither changelog changed. The earlier frozen-install, forced MJS, advisory lint, partial-suite and real-consumer limitations still apply.