SpecsCLIIssue 178 180 Finder Provider Intent Control Implementation Notes: Finder Intent Control
- Execution started from Harness branch
team/stefan/finder-control-envelope at 505ccf68a0184dc6b80cb2148db30be8f63c5aa2.
- Accepted base is
origin/main@694420ca15c8b37536338e85719c6ec00a7154df.
- No open pull request existed at the execution gate; one final PR will be created after implementation and validation.
- Shared source started on checked-out
main at 2c7473179569d237acd3d01a2df055cb76d2e174.
- Collective Intelligence Linear remains read-only. Task identities are planning-only, so no provider lifecycle mutations apply.
- The shared source contains two user-owned pre-existing edits. They are excluded from all worker scopes, staging, commits, and generated projections.
| Check | Result | Notes |
|---|
| Harness branch and base gate | Pass | Current branch team/stefan/finder-control-envelope; merge base 694420ca15c8b37536338e85719c6ec00a7154df. |
| Open PR readback | Pass | gh pr list --head team/stefan/finder-control-envelope --state open returned none. |
| Plan schema and DAG | Pass | Eight tasks; 38 required fields each; acyclic T1 -> T2/T3/T4 -> T5 -> T6 -> T7 -> T8; Prettier and git diff --check passed. |
| Shared-source branch | Pass | /Users/stefan/Desktop/repos/wearedevpunks-skills is on main. |
| Protected shared-source hashes | Pass | AUTHORING-HANDOFF.md: 87ab300221709bb14f8aa0f4aadf785a08fde61a10bc4b1b291740ed035e94c3; state-graph.md: 8c0de318c0c361792ec9410b16116a13289d0f1ea19dcb1c00559d3221220db4. |
| T1 control-envelope contract | Pass | Parent rerun: Node syntax check, 10 focused tests, Biome over all new code/fixture files, and git diff --check. |
| Task | Skill | Status | How/where | Not-applicable reason and assessment location |
|---|
| T1 | codebase-design | applied | validateControlEnvelope centralizes canonical hashing and authority checks; renderRuntimeHandoff projects only eligible validated state. | |
| T1 | tdd | applied | The public contract first failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND, then passed 10 validator/handoff behavior tests. | |
| T2 | codebase-design | loaded | Provider-profile adapter and mutation-planning seam in PLAN T2. | |
| T2 | tdd | loaded | Writer public-result tracer bullets in PLAN T2. | |
| T3 | codebase-design | loaded | Finder routing boundary consumes the envelope result in PLAN T3. | |
| T3 | tdd | loaded | Finder route-fixture tracer bullets in PLAN T3. | |
| T4 | codebase-design | loaded | Requirements correction-record seam in PLAN T4. | |
| T4 | tdd | loaded | Supersession artifact public-result RED/GREEN contract in PLAN T4. | |
| T5 | codebase-design | loaded | Shared-source convergence and retention boundary in PLAN T5. | |
| T6 | codebase-design | loaded | Immutable pin and cache-copy distribution seam in PLAN T6. | |
| T6 | tdd | loaded | Canonical pin expectation RED before production pin in PLAN T6. | |
| T7 | codebase-design | loaded | Authority-derived self-projection and documentation boundary in PLAN T7. | |
| T8 | codebase-design | loaded | Findings-first ownership, dependency, and public-seam review in PLAN T8. | |
| Architecture wave id | Target ownership topology and observed state | Declared dependency graph and observed state | Due criterion ids, evidence, prior-met regression status | Public seam delta | Migration ledger delta, expiry waves, final empty-ledger status | Validation evidence | Verdict or exact drift |
|---|
| A1 | finder-control-envelope.mjs owns validation; runtime-handoff.md owns the generated view contract. Finder/provider consumers remain outside the module for A2 migration. | Tests and reference docs depend only on the two exported seams; the module uses Node crypto and imports no Finder gate or provider adapter. | RAC-001 met by complete/stale/missing authority fixtures; RAC-006 met by eligible-only rendering and fresh-provider stale-handoff rejection. | Added validateControlEnvelope(state, options) -> eligible or typed zero-write rejection and renderRuntimeHandoff(validated) -> Markdown; no existing seam removed. | No seam introduced; ledger remains empty. | node --check; 10 focused Node tests; Biome over script/test/fixture; git diff --check; protected hashes unchanged. | Pass — the boundary is established and A2 consumers may migrate behind it. |
| A2 | Pending W2. | Pending W2. | RAC-002 through RAC-005 pending; A1 regression pending. | Pending. | No planned seams; ledger empty. | Pending. | Pending. |
| A3 | Pending W3. | Pending W3. | A1-A2 regression pending. | Pending. | No planned seams; ledger empty. | Pending. | Pending. |
| A4 | Pending W4-W5. | Pending W4-W5. | RAC-007 pending; prior criteria regression pending. | Pending. | No planned seams; ledger empty. | Pending. | Pending. |
| A5 | Pending W6. | Pending W6. | RAC-001 through RAC-007 final regression pending. | Pending. | No planned seams; ledger empty. | Pending. | Pending. |
| Final closure | Pending. | Pending. | All criteria pending final acceptance audit. | Pending. | Must be empty. | Pending. | Pending. |
| Criterion | Status | Notes |
|---|
| AC-001 through AC-033 | unmet | Implementation and cumulative conformance evidence are in progress. |
| Area | Check | How to perform | Expected result |
|---|
| Shared control contracts | Re-run the issue #178/#180 regression corpus. | Run the focused shared-source Node contract suites recorded in completed T1-T4 plan entries. | Valid current state is eligible; every stale, unsupported, premature, or semantically substituted operation returns a typed zero-write result. |
| Distribution | Confirm one immutable source reaches every agent surface. | Compare the final shared remote SHA, Harness pin, cache receipt, CLI bundle, and selected .agents mirrors using the commands recorded in T5-T7. | Every retained projection is byte-identical to the pushed shared source; protected user edits are absent. |
| Release scope | Confirm classification without publication. | Run bun run release:classify -- --base origin/main --head HEAD. | Classifier returns baseline; CHANGELOG.md is unchanged and no baseline is published. |
/Users/stefan/Desktop/repos/wearedevpunks-skills/skills/phases/finder-phase/AUTHORING-HANDOFF.md is user-modified and excluded./Users/stefan/Desktop/repos/wearedevpunks-skills/skills/phases/finder-phase/references/state-graph.md is user-modified and excluded.
- Execute and validate W1 through W6, run final acceptance and architecture closure, push the Harness branch, and create its one final PR.
| Date | Feedback | Changes |
|---|
| 2026-09-01 | Make the system maximally agent-intuitive, ergonomic, accretive, coherent, and resource-efficient while addressing issues #178 and #180. | Locked a provider-neutral control envelope, correction epochs, exact mutation bindings, generated handoff, provider projection profiles, and executable incident fixtures. |